Quantitative genetics of growth and cryptic evolution of body size in an island population

Evolutionary Ecology (Impact Factor: 2.37). 01/2007; 21(3):337-356. DOI: 10.1007/s10682-006-9106-z

ABSTRACT While evolution occurs when selection acts on a heritable trait, empirical studies of natural systems have frequently reported
phenotypic stasis under these conditions. We performed quantitative genetic analyses of weight and hindleg length in a free-living
population of Soay sheep (Ovis aries) to test whether genetic constraints can explain previously reported stasis in body size despite evidence for strong positive
directional selection. Genetic, maternal and environmental covariance structures were estimated across ontogeny using random
regression animal models. Heritability increased with age for weight and hindleg length, though both measures of size were
highly heritable across ontogeny. Genetic correlations among ages were generally strong and uniformly positive, and the covariance
structures were also highly integrated across ontogeny. Consequently, we found no constraint to the evolution of larger size
itself. Rather we expect size at all ages to increase in response to positive selection acting at any age. Consistent with
expectation, predicted breeding values for age-specific size traits have increased over a twenty-year period, while maternal
performance for offspring size has declined. Re-examination of the phenotypic data confirmed that sheep are not getting larger,
but also showed that there are significant negative trends in size at all ages. The genetic evolution is therefore cryptic,
with the response to selection presumably being masked at the phenotypic level by a plastic response to changing environmental
conditions. Density-dependence, coupled with systematically increasing population size, may contribute to declining body size
but is insufficient to completely explain it. Our results demonstrate that an increased understanding of the genetic basis
of quantitative traits, and of how plasticity and microevolution can occur simultaneously, is necessary for developing predictive
models of phenotypic change in nature.

Download full-text


Available from: Alastair J Wilson, Jun 17, 2015
1 Follower
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Offspring size affects survival and subsequent reproduction in many organisms. However, studies of offspring size in large mammals are often limited to effects on juveniles because of the difficulty of following individuals to maturity. We used data from a long-term study of individually marked gray seals (Halichoerus grypus; Fabricius, 1791) to test the hypothesis that larger offspring have higher survival to recruitment and are larger and more successful primiparous mothers than smaller offspring. Between 1998 and 2002, 1182 newly weaned female pups were branded with unique permanent marks on Sable Island, Canada. Each year through 2012, all branded females returning to the breeding colony were identified in weekly censuses and a subset were captured and measured. Females that survived were significantly longer offspring than those not sighted, indicating size-selective mortality between weaning and recruitment. The probability of female survival to recruitment varied among cohorts and increased nonlinearly with body mass at weaning. Beyond 51.5 kg (mean population weaning mass) weaning mass did not influence the probability of survival. The probability of female survival to recruitment increased monotonically with body length at weaning. Body length at primiparity was positively related to her body length and mass at weaning. Three-day postpartum mass (proxy for birth mass) of firstborn pups was also positively related to body length of females when they were weaned. However, females that were longer or heavier when they were weaned did not wean heavier firstborn offspring.
    Ecology and Evolution 03/2015; 5(7). DOI:10.1002/ece3.1450 · 1.66 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Understanding the evolutionary processes that dictate biological diversity in nature is critical to making predictions about how animals will respond to future environmental change. Despite this, few have been able to overcome the logistic constraints that accompany such studies in the wild. Large marine vertebrates are particularly troublesome owing to their cryptic nature and high vagility, which also leads some researchers to believe that local adaptation will be rare. And yet cases are mounting in which marine organisms, with high dispersal potential, are phenotypically divergent over small spatial scales. In this thesis, I use quantitative genetic methods to provide supporting evidence for local adaptation in a large marine vertebrate, the lemon shark (Negaprion brevirostris). My study takes advantage of samples obtained from an isolated lemon shark nursery lagoon since 1995 (Bimini, Bahamas), as well as data collected opportunistically at another site in the Florida Keys (Marquesas Key). This system is particularly interesting owing to the differences in juvenile body size and growth rate between sites. I begin this thesis by using newly developed microsatellite markers to reconstruct population pedigrees, and by then characterizing the mating system of the lemon shark in light of early life history differences. Mating system patterns were consistent among sites ─ adult females showed high fidelity to each nursery for parturition and mated with multiple males (i.e., polyandry). The observed polyandry could not be explained by direct or indirect genetic benefits, and so I instead suggest that females mate multiply to avoid harassment by males. I next estimated selection and heritability associated with morphological traits in sharks at Bimini, finding that small, slow growing individuals were favored, and that some of these traits were heritable. These findings support a scenario of “constrained” local adaptation, whereby juveniles are partially adapted to their respective nursery sites but divergent pressures acting on other life stages, along with male-mediated dispersal, likely maintains strong selection and high heritability. In summary, my thesis shows that quantitative genetics can be used to understand evolutionary processes influencing biodiversity in large marine vertebrates. Future research will benefit from further considering the relationship between local adaptation and gene flow in vagile marine organisms. Afin de prédire comment les animaux vont réagir aux futurs changements environnementaux, il est important de comprendre les processus évolutionnaires qui dictent la biodiversité de la nature. Par contre, peu ont pu surmonter les contraintes logistiques qui accompagnent de telles études sur le terrain. Les gros vertébrés marins sont particulièrement difficiles en raison de leur nature énigmatique et très ambulatoire. Ceci mène certains chercheurs à croire que l’adaptation locale sera très rare. Cependant, il y a une augmentation de cas ou les organismes marins, avec un haut potentiel de se propager, divergent de façon phénotypique sur des petites échelles spatiales. Dans cette thèse, j’utilise des méthodes génétiques quantitatives afin de supporter l’hypothèse de l’adaptation locale d’un gros vertébré marin, le requin citron (Negaprion brevirostris). Mon étude exploite les échantillons obtenus depuis 1995 d’une pouponnière de requins citron située dans une lagune isolée (Bimini, Bahamas), ainsi que des données récoltées de façon opportune à un autre site dans les Florida Keys (Marquesas Key). Ce system d’étude est particulièrement intéressant à cause des différences de taille des juvéniles ainsi que des taux de croissance entre les sites. Je débute cette thèse en utilisant des marqueurs microsatellitaires, afin de reconstruire le pedigree des populations. Ceci me permet de caractériser le système d’accouplement des requins citron à la lumière des différences des antécédents de leur jeune vie. Les patrons du système d’accouplement étaient consistants entre les sites – les femelles adultes ont démontré une fidélité élevée à chaque pouponnière pour la parturition et elles se sont accouplés avec plusieurs males (i.e., polyandre). Nous ne pouvons pas expliquer la polyandre que nous avons observé par des bénéfices directs ou indirects. Alors je suggère que les femelles s’accouplent avec plusieurs males afin d’éviter d’être harceler par ceux-ci. Par la suite, j’ai estimé la sélection et l’héritabilité associé avec les traits morphologiques des requins à Bimini, et j’ai découvert que les petits individus à croissance lente était favori, et que certains traits étaient héritables. Ces découvertes supportent un scénario d’adaptation local contraint, par lequel les juvéniles sont partiellement adaptés à leur pouponnière respective. Par contre, des pressions divergentes agissent à d’autres stages de leur vie et, avec la dispersion des males, il est probable que cela maintien une sélection forte et une haute héritabilité. En résumé, ma thèse démontre que la génétique quantitative peut être utilisée afin de comprendre le processus d’évolution qui influence la diversité biologique dans les gros vertébrés marins. A l’avenir, la recherche pourra bénéficier en prenant en considération la relation entre l’adaptation locale et la transmission de gène dans les organismes marins ambulatoire.
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Darwin's evolutionary theory could easily explain the evolution of adaptive traits (organs and behavioral patterns) in asexual but not in sexual organisms. Two models, the selfish gene theory and frozen plasticity theory were suggested to explain evolution of adaptive traits in sexual organisms in past 30 years. The frozen plasticity theory suggests that sexual species can evolve new adaptations only when their members are genetically uniform, i.e. only after a portion of the population of the original species had split off, balanced on the edge of extinction for several generations, and then undergone rapid expansion. After a short period of time, estimated on the basis of paleontological data to correspond to 1-2% of the duration of the species, polymorphism accumulates in the gene pool due to frequency-dependent selection; and thus, in each generation, new mutations occur in the presence of different alleles and therefore change their selection coefficients from generation to generation. The species ceases to behave in an evolutionarily plastic manner and becomes evolutionarily elastic on a microevolutionary time-scale and evolutionarily frozen on a macroevolutionary time-scale. It then exists in this state until such changes accumulate in the environment that the species becomes extinct. Frozen plasticity theory, which includes the Darwinian model of evolution as a special case--the evolution of species in a plastic state, not only offers plenty of new predictions to be tested, but also provides explanations for a much broader spectrum of known biological phenomena than classic evolutionary theories. This article was reviewed by Rob Knight, Fyodor Kondrashov and Massimo Di Giulio (nominated by David H. Ardell).
    Biology Direct 01/2010; 5(1):2. DOI:10.1186/1745-6150-5-2 · 4.04 Impact Factor