Causes of recent changes in western North American snowpack

Climate Dynamics (Impact Factor: 4.62). 05/2011; 38(9):1885-1899. DOI: 10.1007/s00382-011-1089-y

ABSTRACT Monthly snow water equivalent (SWE) station observations and gridded temperature data are used to identify mechanisms by which
warming affects the temporal and geographical structure of changes in western North American mountain snowpack. We first exploit
interannual variability to demonstrate the sensitivity of snowpack to temperature during the various phases of the snow season.
We show that mechanisms whereby temperature affects snowpack emerge in the mid to late portion of the snow season (March through
May), but are nearly absent during the earliest phase (February), when temperatures are generally well below freezing. The
mid to late snow season is precisely when significant loss of snowpack is seen at nearly all locations over the past few decades,
both through decreases in snow accumulation and increases in snowmelt. At locations where April 1st SWE has been increasing
over the past few decades, the increase is entirely due to a significant enhancement of accumulation during the earliest phase
of the snow season, when the sensitivity analysis indicates that temperature is not expected to affect snowpack. Later in
the snow season, these stations exhibit significant snowpack loss comparable to the other stations. Based on this analysis,
it is difficult to escape the conclusion that recent snowpack changes in western North America are caused by regional-scale
warming. Given predictions of future warming, a further reduction in late season snowpack and advancement in the onset of
snowmelt should be expected in the coming decades throughout the region.

KeywordsSnow water equivalent–Climate change–Climate sensitivity–Trends–Surface observations

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: An important and largely unaddressed issue in studies of biotic-abiotic relationships is the extent to which closely related species, or species living in similar habitats, have similar responses to weather. We addressed this by applying a hierarchical, Bayesian analytical framework to a long-term data set for butterflies which allowed us to simultaneously investigate responses of the entire fauna and individual species. A small number of variables had community-level effects. In particular, higher total annual snow depth had a positive effect on butterfly occurrences, while spring minimum temperature and El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) sea-surface variables for April-May had negative standardized coefficients. Our most important finding was that variables with large impacts at the community-level did not necessarily have a consistent response across all species. Species-level responses were much more similar to each other for snow depth compared to the other variables with strong community effects. This variation in species-level responses to weather variables raises important complications for the prediction of biotic responses to shifting climatic conditions. In addition, we found that clear associations with weather can be detected when considering ecologically delimited subsets of the community. For example, resident species and non-ruderal species had a much more unified response to weather variables compared to non-resident species and ruderal species, which suggests local adaptation to climate. These results highlight the complexity of biotic-abiotic interactions and confront that complexity with methodological advances that allow ecologists to understand communities and shifting climates while simultaneously revealing species-specific variation in response to climate.
    Ecology 08/2014; 95(8):2155-68. · 5.00 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Empirical sensitivity analyses are important for evaluation of the effects of a changing climate on water resources and ecosystems. Although mechanistic models are commonly applied for evaluation of climate effects for snowmelt, empirical relationships provide a first-order validation of the various postulates required for their implementation. Previous studies of empirical sensitivity for April 1 snow water equivalent (SWE) in the western United States were developed by regressing interannual variations in SWE to winter precipitation and temperature. This offers a temporal analog for climate change, positing that a warmer future looks like warmer years. Spatial analogs are used to hypothesize that a warmer future may look like warmer places, and are frequently applied alternatives for complex processes, or states/metrics that show little interannual variability (e.g. forest cover). We contrast spatial and temporal analogs for sensitivity of April 1 SWE and the mean residence time of snow (SRT) using data from 524 Snowpack Telemetry (SNOTEL) stations across the western US. We built relatively strong models using spatial analogs to relate temperature and precipitation climatology to snowpack climatology (April 1 SWE, R2=0.87, and SRT, R2=0.81). Although the poorest temporal analog relationships were in areas showing the highest sensitivity to warming, spatial analog models showed consistent performance throughout the range of temperature and precipitation. Generally, slopes from the spatial relationships showed greater thermal sensitivity than the temporal analogs, and high elevation stations showed greater vulnerability using a spatial analog than shown in previous modeling and sensitivity studies. The spatial analog models provide a simple perspective to evaluate potential futures and may be useful in further evaluation of snowpack with warming.
    Water Resources Research. 11/2014;
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The high mountains of Asia, including the Karakoram, Himalayas and Tibetan Plateau, combine to form a region of perplexing hydroclimate changes. Glaciers have exhibited mass stability or even expansion in the Karakoram region1, 2, 3, contrasting with glacial mass loss across the nearby Himalayas and Tibetan Plateau1, 4, a pattern that has been termed the Karakoram anomaly. However, the remote location, complex terrain and multi-country fabric of high-mountain Asia have made it difficult to maintain longer-term monitoring systems of the meteorological components that may have influenced glacial change. Here we compare a set of high-resolution climate model simulations from 1861 to 2100 with the latest available observations to focus on the distinct seasonal cycles and resulting climate change signatures of Asia’s high-mountain ranges. We find that the Karakoram seasonal cycle is dominated by non-monsoonal winter precipitation, which uniquely protects it from reductions in annual snowfall under climate warming over the twenty-first century. The simulations show that climate change signals are detectable only with long and continuous records, and at specific elevations. Our findings suggest a meteorological mechanism for regional differences in the glacier response to climate warming.
    Nature Geoscience 11/2014; 7:834-840. · 11.67 Impact Factor

Full-text (2 Sources)

Available from
Sep 25, 2014