Ecological implications of Cousinia Cass. (Asteraceae) persistence through the last two glacial-interglacial cycles in the continental Middle East for the Irano-Turanian flora

Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology (Impact Factor: 1.66). 02/2012; 172. DOI: 10.1016/j.revpalbo.2012.01.005

ABSTRACT This study explores the response of the Irano-Turanian flora to Quaternary glacial–interglacial cycles in SW Asia. We use new fossil pollen data to assess variation in abundance of Cousinia Cass. (Compositae), a large genus typical for the Irano-Turanian flora, during these cycles. The results are compared with modern topography, tectonic and palaeoclimatic history, and recent phylogenetic data to explain the extremely high speciation rate and level of endemism as well as the modern geographical distribution of the genus. Cousinia is consistently well-represented in glacial-age and late-glacial pollen assemblages of NW Iran and E Anatolia. In the ~ 200,000-year pollen sequence from Lake Urmia, NW Iran, Cousinia pollen shows significant values and is nearly continuously represented during both the last glacial (~ 70 ka to Holocene) and penultimate glacial periods (~ 190 to 130 ka). In contrast, its pollen is less frequent and occurs only sporadically during the last interglacial period and the Holocene. This pattern suggests that Cousinia could not only withstand Quaternary glaciations, but was a significant part of the glacial-age landscapes of the Irano-Turanian territory. We argue that the extremely high rate of speciation and endemism of Cousinia is due to (i) the continuous presence of a complex topography in the Middle East and Central Asia since Tertiary times, which created a wide range of environmental niches and facilitated the formation and persistence of isolated populations over long periods, (ii) relatively stable climate during the late Miocene–Pliocene compared to the Quaternary period that caused small species range shifts and gene flow, and (iii) a dampened impact of multiple glacial–interglacial cycles on the mountain regions of SW Asia compared to the higher latitude European mountain ranges. This left an extensive, non-glaciated altitudinal zone for the survival of Irano-Turanian species, thereby reducing extinction during glacial periods. During interglacial periods, many Cousinia species may have been geographically isolated in high mountain “interglacial refugia” of the Irano-Turanian region. Overall, the combination of the above factors during the Neogene resulted in geographical isolation and reduced gene flow, thereby fostering allopatric speciation in Cousinia and probably also in many other speciose Irano-Turanian plant taxa.

1 Follower
  • Biologia 01/2015; 7(3). · 0.70 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The lacustrine sediments in Vorotan Basin (Armenia) have been examined palynologically. The results were used to reconstruct the vegetation history in the Southern Caucasus during parts of the early Pleistocene. The sediments consisted of diatomaceous clay, silt and fine sand, where pollen shows good and plant macrofossils show excellent preservation. Combination of palaeomagnetic and 39Ar/40Ar-method delivers a reliable dating of the sediments: they are covering the beginning of mid Pleistocene transition (1?110?–?960 ka). At ten outcrops 506 sediment samples were taken for pollen examination. A total of 64 different pollen taxa have been determined. They were summarized in pollen profiles and underwent an ecological interpretation. In addition all data were analysed statistically in a factor analysis and a cluster analysis. Their results are also included in the pollen profiles. The pollen profiles clearly show regional vegetation cycles during early Pleistocene. These cycles are described and compared with some results of other authors within the whole Mediterranean. Additionally relations to modern vegetation in the Southern Caucasus and adjacent areas are drawn. Palaeovegetation in Southern Caucasus shows a mosaic of grass steppe with more or less open forests. According to climate there are influences of neighbouring vegetation zones: boreal conifer forest of the Caucasus heights, thermophile deciduous forest of the euxinian and hyrcanian regions, xerothermous steppe of northern Iran. During interglacials an open forest with thermophile deciduous taxa (e.?g. Quercus, ­Carpinus, Ulmus, Zelkova, Tilia) occurs. During pronounced warming grass steppe areas are dominating whereas forests are pushed back to northern slopes and riparian areas. In glacial phases conifers are becoming increasingly important (e.?g. Tsuga, Abies, Picea, Pinus), finally leading to a closed pine forest at the end of the first long lasting glacial MIS 30. It becomes clear that the climate cycles differ significantly in the character of the according vegetation. For that amplitude of warming as well as duration of the phase play the most important role. The comparison with other investigations shows that vegetation cycles in Southern Caucasus are partly completely different to those in western, central and eastern Mediterranean. There is a „vegetation gradient“ along the east-west-axis. These results have some consequences to the interpretation of early human dispersals out of Africa into Eurasia. It seems obvious that not every vegetation cycle is convenient for the expansion of human population. In Southern Caucasus there were suitable conditions (open landscape, vegetation mosaic, warm climate) at pronounced interglacial phases. On the contrary long lasting glacial phases brought more hostile conditions for Homo erectus. As in southern regions of Europe the vegetation had been partly extremely different during certain climatic phases, it seems obvious that Southern Caucasus played an important part as a refuge for early humans. Vegetation changes at the transition from obliquity induced 41 ka cycles to eccentricity induced 100 ka cycles (mid Pleistocene transition) are very clearly shown by the results. These changes surely influenced the human population at that time and may have caused migrations and/or adaptations. Possibly they even have caused the beginning of cultural development, such as the utilization of fire.
    06/2013, Degree: PhD, Supervisor: Angela A. Bruch
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: A well-dated suite of Lake Van climate-proxy data covering the last 360 ka documents environmental changes over 4 glacial/interglacial cycles in Eastern Anatolia, Turkey. The picture of cold and dry glacials and warm and wet interglacials emerging from pollen, organic carbon, authigenic carbonate content, elemental profiling by XRF and lithological analyses is inconsistent with classical interpretation of ox-ygen isotopic composition of carbonates pointing to a more complex pattern in Lake Van region. Detailed analysis of glacial terminations allows for the constraining of a depositional model explaining different patterns observed in all the proxies. We hypothesize that variations in relative contribution of rainfall, snowmelt and glacier meltwater recharging the basin have a very important role for all sedimentary processes in Lake Van. Lake level of glacial Lake Van, predominantly fed by snowmelt, was low, the water column was oxic, and carbonates precipitating in the epilimnion recorded the light isotopic signature of inflow. During terminations, increasing rainfall and significant supply of mountain glaciers' meltwater contributed to lake level rise. Increased rainfall enhanced density gradients in the water column, and hindered mixing leading to development of bottom-water anoxia. Carbonates precipitating during terminations show large fluctuations in their isotopic composition. Full interglacial conditions in Lake Van are characterized by high or slowly falling lake level. Rainfall and snowmelt feed the lake but due to re-established mixing, the isotopic composition of authigenic carbonates is heavier and closer to that of evaporation-influenced lake water than that of runoff representing snowmelt and atmospheric precipitation.
    Quaternary Science Reviews 11/2014; 104. DOI:10.1016/j.quascirev.2014.07.001 · 4.57 Impact Factor


Available from
May 21, 2014