Racial Differences Between African and White Americans in the Presentation of Borderline Personality Disorder

Race and Social Problems 1(2):87-96. DOI: 10.1007/s12552-009-9006-2

ABSTRACT Borderline personality disorder (BPD) is commonly thought of as a disorder of White females. Despite evidence indicating similar
prevalence rates across races and genders, no study has examined the experience of BPD among ethnic minorities and how this
differs from Whites. The affective and behavioral symptoms of BPD were studied in 17 African Americans and 27 White Americans
with the disorder. Results indicated that African Americans experience greater affective intensity and emotional dysregulation,
fewer self-harming behaviors, and more thoughts of interpersonal aggression than Whites. Differences in affective symptoms
were accounted for by group differences in substance use and receipt of inpatient services, whereas differences in behavioral
symptomatology persisted after adjusting for potential confounders. These findings suggest that not only is BPD not a disorder
exclusive to White females, but that the experience of the disorder may differ substantially across races. Implications for
future research and directions for developing culturally relevant treatments are discussed.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Until recently, many researchers have been sceptical about any relationship between psychiatric disorders and violence. Since public opinion has always been prejudiced against the mentally ill, professionals in the field of psychiatry have been very cautious about further stigmatizing individuals with psychiatric illnesses. The authors have reviewed studies of mental disorders and violence, particularly the most recent, and find that there is increasing evidence for an association between psychiatric disorders and violence. Recent data suggest that the combination of previous violent behavior, alcoholism and antisocial personality disorder markedly increases the risk of future violent behavior. Schizophrenia, personality disorders and alcoholism per se do not increase the risk of violent behavior as much as do the above factors, but the risk among these diagnostic groups is, however, notably higher than that in the general population. The authors emphasize that only a minority of patients with mental disorders are violent. Future research is needed to better identify and treat these potentially violent patients.
    International Journal of Psychiatry in Clinical Practice - INT J PSYCHIATR CLIN PRACT. 01/1997; 1(3):179-188.
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In a survey of borderline personality disorder, 23 studies that included data on age, sex, or race of the patient samples were identified. Comparison of patients who had borderline personality disorder with control groups in these studies revealed that a significant preponderance of patients with the disorder were young, white, and female. This finding cannot be considered conclusive because data were pooled from studies with questionable sampling techniques. Yet, this demographic profile warrants confirmation because it may imply diagnostic biases or actual differences in the prevalence of borderline personality disorder among various groups.
    The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 05/1986; 47(4):196-8. · 5.81 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The purpose of this study was to examine cross-ethnic differences in Perception of Emotion (POE) in schizophrenia. POE is an emerging construct in schizophrenia and involves the recognition and accurate identification of emotion in the facial and vocal expression of others. It has been implicated as relevant to instrumental functioning in schizophrenia, as well as a potential core deficit or marker for the disorder. Studies have shown the role of culture in shaping the expression and perception of emotion in non-clinical samples. It was hypothesized that ethnic minorities would have lower POE scores than Caucasians, and that the differences on POE would remain significant after controlling for neurocognition. Individuals, 131, diagnosed with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder participated in the study. There were 59 Euro-American Caucasian, 56 were African-American, and 16 were Latino. Neurocognition was measured as a standardized sum of five neuropsychological measures. Perception of Emotion was measured with facial and voice recognition tasks. Both Latinos and African-Americans scored lower on POE than Caucasians. The cross-ethnic differences on POE remained significant after controlling for neurocognition and overall symptom level. Post hoc analyses showed some support for the predictive validity of the POE measure across cultural contexts. These results suggest that POE in schizophrenia is influenced by ethnicity, and that the ethno-cultural mechanisms influencing POE transcend the shared variation of POE and neurocognition. These results have implications for theories of cross-cultural emotion recognition, measurement bias in POE research, and for the place of culture in the study of POE in schizophrenia.
    Schizophrenia Research 10/2005; 77(2-3):289-98. · 4.59 Impact Factor


Available from
May 22, 2014