Article

Life cycle assessment of integrated circuit packaging technologies

The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment (Impact Factor: 3.09). 16(3):258-267. DOI: 10.1007/s11367-011-0260-3

ABSTRACT Background, aim and scope
Nanostructured polymer particles are produced to be used in ball grid array (BGA) and chip scale packaging (CSP). The technology could replace conventional BGA and CSP metal balls, and the hypothesis is that the shift could be eco-efficient as polymer core particles increase the reliability. For the first time, these particles are environmentally evaluated.

Materials and methods
The change in GWP100 and Eco-Indicator’99 (H) scores when replacing traditional component packaging, here quad flat pack to BGA/CSP, was explored both on component and printed circuit board assembly (PCBA) level. This was followed by comparisons between BGA packages using different types of metal-plated monodispersed polymer particle (MPP) balls and conventional balls, respectively.

Results and discussion
For BGAs, the silicon (Si) die dominates CO2e emissions, but for Eco-Indicator’99(H), solder balls are not negligible. Excluding the Si die and component assembly, the LFBGA-84 to WCSP-64 would reduce CO2e by about 98% and Eco-Indicator’99 (H) by about 90%. Overall, for BGA–256 using same size balls, gold-plated MPP technology decreases the Eco-Indicator’99(H) score by about 25% compared to Pb-based or Pb-free balls. Gold production dominated GWP100 and Eco-Indicator’99 (H) for the gold-plated MPP. Each microsystem is unique, and new environmental impact estimations must be done for the sub-structures of each electronic device. Screening process-sum life cycle assessment (LCA) gives similar understanding of impacts as resource productivity methods. Even though the metal mass per ball is greatly reduced, it is a weak indicator of environmental impacts which are driven by each material’s specific environmental characteristics.

Conclusions
The ball share of the BGA-256 GWP100 and Eco-Indicator’99 (H) score is small, and the BGA/CSP producers can marginally improve the environmental performance by focusing on the balls. On a comparable IC packaging basis, the introduction of WCSP packaging technology implies a significant environmental footprint reduction. On PCBA level, the contribution of BGA balls is negligible. Results for metal-plated MPP BGA balls suggest that gold usage is the key environmental performance indicator of interest.

Recommendations and perspectives
Even though WCSP clearly reduces the component level impacts, the PCBA (board) level impact could increase as the CSP miniaturisation is paralleled with more PWB layers. This effect should be included in further system expansions. For LCA, in general, update of all LCIA methods, which include ozone depletion, with the latest results for dinitrogen monoxide is needed.
Keywords Ball grid array – Chip scale package – Electronic device – Integrated circuit – Monodispersed polymer particle – Printed circuit board assembly – Screening LCA

6 Bookmarks
 · 
466 Views
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Here attributional life cycle assessments (LCAs) for the same smartphone model are presented by two different organizations (Orange, OGE and Huawei, HuW) and the effect of different modeling approach is analyzed. A difference of around 32% (29.6 kg and 39.2 kg) for CO2e baseline scores is found using same study object and sector specific LCA standard, however, different metrics, emission intensities, and LCA software programs. The CO2e difference is reduced to 12% (29.9 kg and 33.5 kg) when OGE use HuW metrics for use phase power consumption and total mass, and when HuW use OGE metrics for gold mass and silicon die area. Further, a probability test confirms that present baseline climate change results, for one specific study object modeled with two largely different and independent LCA modeling approaches, are comparable if both use the European Telecommunications Standard Institute (ETSI) LCA standard. The general conclusion is that the ETSI LCA standard strongly facilitates comparable CC results for technically comparable smartphone models. Moreover, thanks to the reporting requirements of ETSI LCA standard, a clear understanding of the differences between LCA modeling approaches is obtained. The research also discusses the magnitude of the CO2e reduction potential in the life cycle of smartphones.
    Challenges. 11/2014; 5(2):409-429.
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In product development in the industry, it is important to estimate the environmental impact of each product in a logical and applicable way. However, the quantity of requirements can act as a barrier to introducing eco-design. Few methods have been presented that clearly describes how eco-design can really become a part of the traditional product development process. Several existing eco-design methods do not seem to be intended for rapid product development process where the eco-design is not the main objective. Here an approach for rapid introduction of eco-design of electronics in the product development process of any company is presented. The cost-effective method makes use of seven eco-metrics and rapid LCA giving quantified results which are easily understood by designers. The proposed method captures the essence of eco-design of electronics in a cost-effective manner with enough precision for use as designer information. The actual implementation and verification of eco-design changes are solved and moreover the proposed eco-design method does not require specific customization prior to use. The presented method is successfully demonstrated for the development of a mobile phone.
    Going Green CARE Innovation, Vienna, Austria; 11/2014
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In product development in the industry, it is important to estimate the environmental impact of each product in a logical and applicable way. However, the quantity of requirements can act as a barrier to introducing eco-design. Few methods have been presented that clearly describes how eco-design can really become a part of the traditional product development process. Several existing eco-design methods do not seem to be intended for rapid product development process where the eco-design is not the main objective. Here an approach for rapid introduction of eco-design of electronics in the product development process of any company is presented. The cost-effective method makes use of seven eco-metrics and rapid LCA giving quantified results which are easily understood by designers. The proposed method captures the essence of eco-design of electronics in a cost-effective manner with enough precision for use as designer information. The actual implementation and verification of eco-design changes are solved and moreover the proposed eco-design method does not require specific customization prior to use. The presented method is successfully demonstrated for the development of a mobile phone.