A Methodology for Determining the Return on Investment Associated With Prognostics and Health Management

Dept. of Mech. Eng., Univ. of Maryland, College Park, MD
IEEE Transactions on Reliability (Impact Factor: 2.29). 07/2009; DOI: 10.1109/TR.2009.2020133
Source: IEEE Xplore

ABSTRACT Prognostics and Health Management (PHM) provides opportunities for lowering sustainment costs, improving maintenance decision-making, and providing product usage feedback into the product design and validation process. However, support for PHM is predicated on the articulation of clear business cases that quantify the expected cost and benefits of its implementation. The realization of PHM requires implementation at different levels of scale, and complexity. The maturity, robustness, and applicability of the underlying predictive algorithms impact the overall efficacy of PHM within an enterprise. The utility of PHM to inform decision-makers within tight scheduling constraints, and under different operational profiles likewise affects the cost avoidance that can be realized. This paper discusses the calculation of Return on Investment (ROI) for PHM activities, and presents a study conducted using a stochastic discrete event simulation model to determine the potential ROI offered by electronics PHM. The case study of a multifunctional display in a Boeing 737 compares the life cycle costs of a system employing unscheduled maintenance to the same system using a precursor to failure PHM approach.

  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Most engineered systems are designed with a passive and fixed design capacity and, therefore, may become unreliable in the presence of adverse events. Currently, most engi-neered systems are designed with system redundancies to ensure required system reliabil-ity under adverse events. However, a high level of system redundancy increases a system's life-cycle cost (LCC). Recently, proactive maintenance decisions have been enabled through the development of prognostics and health management (PHM) methods that detect, diagnose, and predict the effects of adverse events. Capitalizing on PHM technology at an early design stage can transform passively reliable (or vulnerable) sys-tems into adaptively reliable (or resilient) systems while considerably reducing their LCC. In this paper, we propose a resilience-driven system design (RDSD) framework with the goal of designing complex engineered systems with resilience characteristics. This design framework is composed of three hierarchical tasks: (i) the resilience alloca-tion problem (RAP) as a top-level design problem to define a resilience measure as a function of reliability and PHM efficiency in an engineering context, (ii) the system reliability-based design optimization (RBDO) as the first bottom-level design problem for the detailed design of components, and (iii) the system PHM design as the second bottom-level design problem for the detailed design of PHM units. The proposed RDSD framework is demonstrated using a simplified aircraft control actuator design problem resulting in a highly resilient actuator with optimized reliability, PHM efficiency and re-dundancy for the given parameter settings. [DOI: 10.1115/1.4004981]
    Journal of Mechanical Design 10/2011; 133(10):101011(15). · 1.25 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Pushed by digital systems development and the pressure to reduce costs, in the last 40 years health monitoring (Hm) capabilities evolved from simple Built In Tests to system health prognostics, causing the development of new maintenance and operation concepts and new business models. Hm functions allow business growth by maximizing availability, optimizing the logistics, improving productivity and reducing maintenance costs and nowadays they have assumed a central role in aviation business. This role has to be captured by Hm system providers in order to fully exploit the opportunities provided by the market. To define Hm requirements is a very complex task as it necessitates considering many complex interrelated aspects such as costs reduction, concept of operations and business models. Nevertheless very little guidance exists about Hm requirements capture and this gap represents one of the main blockers to the diffusion of Hm systems. This work will then try defining a structured way to produce good Hm high level requirements. House of Quality (HoQ) has been identified as a structured but flexible methodology, which allows taking into account all the complexity of Hm and integrating business, maintenance and operational aspects. The research guideline for the design of the Hm HoQ matrices is based on the understanding of the economic value created by Hm and on the results of the total life asset cost analysis. The use of the proposed method has been demonstrated and validated through case studies where the high level Hm requirements for a metering valve and a landing gear monitoring system have been investigated. The results obtained in this phase proved that the methodology is credible as it confirmed some of the conclusions previously obtained by using traditional approaches; in addition to this new aspects are brought into consideration, making the requirements definition process more complete.
    IEEE Aerospace Conference, Big Sky MT; 02/2014
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: For electronic systems equipped with early warning devices known as canaries, the early warning of failure can provide the opportunity for better spare-parts ordering, timely replacement of parts, and a resulting reduction in system life cycle costs. This paper presents both theoretical and simulation-based models for spare-part ordering and system replacement decisions for systems equipped with canaries. We first develop a theoretical model for the expected total cost per unit time in terms of the order interval, and maximum allowable stock level. This model is then compared with a simulation algorithm to validate the model. On the basis of the simulation algorithm, at each ordering point, we remove the constraint of a maximum allowable stock level, and order a quantity proportional to the predicted replacement quantity based on the expected number of canary warnings over the next order period. We then further expand the model to consider the risk (after a canary warning) with respect to the expected cost for delaying the replacement until the next order arrival point if a spare is not available, and then decide whether to replace the system immediately or wait. Finally, we consider the case where a preventive maintenance plan is in place. The comparison using numerical examples among all developed models and algorithms shows that the expected total operating cost in terms of inventory and maintenance is lowered significantly when the canary is used, and particularly when the risk analysis is implemented.
    IEEE Transactions on Reliability 01/2012; 61(2):466-478. · 2.29 Impact Factor


1 Download
Available from