Reliability Evaluation with Weibull Distribution on AC Withstand Voltage Test of Substation Equipment

R&D Center, Tokyo Electr. Power Co., Yokohama
IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation (Impact Factor: 1.23). 11/2008; 15(5):1242 - 1251. DOI: 10.1109/TDEI.2008.4656231
Source: IEEE Xplore

ABSTRACT For the development of a ldquoshort-duration AC withstand voltage testrdquo, an insulation specification of substation equipment, there is a precise method of reliability evaluation using a Weibull distribution function. Regarding this method, there remains a subject of handling coexistence of multiple voltage levels. This paper first defines the two reliability evaluation methods, ldquoindependence methodrdquo; and ldquoaccumulation methodrdquo, applying to Weibull evaluation for coexistence of multiple voltage levels in relation to their physical meanings. Next, the influence of the Weibull parameter values are examined on the cumulative fault probabilities and test voltages calculated using these methods. When the time shape parameter a>1, the accumulation method gives higher values than the independence method; When a=1, the two methods give the same values; When a<1, the former gives lower values than the latter. Then, appropriate reliability evaluation methods are investigated for various insulation media and insulation structures of substation equipment from the viewpoint of inception and development mechanisms of dielectric breakdown and partial discharge. According to the result of engineering evaluation of the presently available data, the independence method may be appropriate for both gas insulated switchgear and oil-immersed transformers.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: To ensure the reliability of oil-immersed power transformers in long-term operation, the influence of aging on various characteristics of their insulating elements must be clarified. The present paper reviewed the degradation status of insulating oil and paper of field-aged transformers, covering investigative results ranging from about 30 years ago to a relatively recent period. The field transformers treated were diverse in terms of their manufacturing year, manufacturer, structure, and voltage class. Despite the examination results of such wide-ranging transformers, there were similar changes in various characteristics due to the aging of insulating oil and paper. For example, as for the insulating oil, due to the aging for about 30 years, the characteristics of the total acid value and volume resistivity had degraded, whereas the breakdown voltage decreased only slightly. Regarding the insulating paper, mechanical characteristics such as the average polymerization degree (DP) were subject to age-related decline, whereas the breakdown voltage did not significantly decrease as with insulating oil. Therefore, based on use of about 30 years, since the life of a transformer is determined by factors such as the degradation of mechanical strength due to thermal stress, insulation degradation is considered less likely to pose a problem at an early stage. Even though it is difficult to directly measure the degree of degradation of insulating paper, this can be indirectly estimated by measuring the CO2 and CO content and furfural content in insulating oil. On the other hand, given the increasing number of transformers remaining in service over 30 years, which had been deemed the expected service life, consideration must be taken to aging degradation of the insulation performance. It emerged that, in order to identify the degree of degradation of these transformers, it was effective to manage the volume resistivity and dielectric loss tangent trends in electric- l terms, the interfacial tension trend in physical terms and the total acid value trend in chemical terms. Analysis of the insulating oil components is also considered an effective means of evaluating aging degradation.
    IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation 02/2013; 20(1):346-355. DOI:10.1109/TDEI.2013.6451376 · 1.23 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The use of nanocomposite polymers as electrical insulating materials has been growing rapidly in recent decades. The base polyethylene properties have been developed by adding small amounts of different fillers to the polyethylene material. It is economically to get polymer development by using cost-fewer nanoparticles; therefore, polyethylene dielectric properties are trapped by presence cost-fewer nanofillers like clay and fumed silica which are importance in development manufacture of power cables products. Dielectric strength is a vital pointer for quality of insulation materials of electrical power applications; hence, experimental measurements have been investigated on ac high voltage breakdown of new cost-fewer polyethylene nanocomposites materials. All experimental results of the new polyethylene nanocomposites have been compared with conventional polyethylene insulation materials; therefore, it has been specified the influence types and their concentrations of cost-fewer nanofillers on dielectric strength of polyethylene nanocomposite insulation materials.
    International Journal of Electrical Power & Energy Systems 01/2015; 64:469–475. DOI:10.1016/j.ijepes.2014.06.075 · 3.43 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In the condition settings of a power-frequency withstand voltage test for substation equipment, an approach based on insulation reliability evaluation using Weibull distribution is available. In this method, temporary overvoltage is evaluated using an “independence model”. This “independence model” assumes no remaining influence of voltage application (i.e. the model obeys the failure probability distribution starting at time 0 each time the voltage is applied). However, the authors have conducted insulation characteristics tests by applying a voltage multiple times at intervals and clarified that the influence of voltage application remains to a certain extent (i.e. the effect assumed in the “accumulation model” appears) as well as the degree of influence depending on the conditions for oil-immersed transformer. The present paper proposes an evaluation method with the degree of influence of voltage application history taken into consideration. In the proposed method, the portions following an “independence model” and an “accumulation model” are respectively assumed and combined after multiplying the relevant coefficient representing the respective degrees of influence. According to the trial calculation based on the proposed method, the required withstand voltage decreased by several percentage points, while it was confirmed that the existing method is on the safer side as a means of evaluating the insulation reliability of temporary overvoltage.
    IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation 08/2012; 19(4):1400-1411. DOI:10.1109/TDEI.2012.6260017 · 1.23 Impact Factor