Assessment and correction of imaging artifacts in skin imaging using fibre-based optical coherence tomography
ABSTRACT This study reports two types of imaging artifacts in 3D optical coherence tomography images of human skin - intensity deficits and geometrical distortion, and describes their reduction through the application of refractive index matching media.
- [show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: Histology represents the gold standard for morphological investigation of the skin, though biopsy may alter the original morphology, is non-repeatable on the same site and always requires an iatrogenic trauma. In the past decade, advances in optics, fibre as well as laser technology have enabled the development of a novel non-invasive optical biomedical imaging technique, optical coherence tomography (OCT). The latter is based on a classic optical measurement method known as low-coherence interferometry that enables non-invasive, high resolution, two- or three-dimensional, cross-sectional imaging of microstructural morphology in biological tissue in situ. Using conventional OCT with a lateral resolution of 10-15 microm, the stratum corneum of glabrous skin (palmoplantar), the epidermis and the upper dermis can usually be identified, as well as skin appendages and blood vessels. For example, non-invasive monitoring of cutaneous inflammation, hyperkeratotic conditions and photoadaptive processes is possible by means of OCT. Furthermore, the development of high-output broadband light sources, e.g. femtosecond Ti:sapphire laser, might soon enable ultrahigh image resolutions of about 1 microm in order to investigate skin tissue on the cellular level, which could potentially allow the differentiation between benign and malignant tissues. Beyond a high resolution morphology in OCT images, tissue characterization by additional local physical parameters, such as the scattering coefficient and refractive index may be of great value, in particular in cosmetics and the pharmaceutical industry. Functional OCT imaging based on spectroscopy, tissue birefringence, elastography and Doppler flow reveals further information on tissue properties and represents an important progress of OCT technique in the field of dermatology. Therefore, the advanced versions of OCT technique might not only lead to significant new insights in skin physiology and pathology, but also in diagnosis and therapeutic control of cutaneous disorders with respect to non-invasive diagnosis of conditions and monitoring of disease activity in addition to treatment effects over time.Journal of Dermatological Science 12/2005; 40(2):85-94. · 3.52 Impact Factor
- [show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: Optical coherence tomography (OCT) is a new noninvasive imaging technique. In this study, it was used for the investigation of contact dermatitis and psoriasis. In these common inflammatory skin diseases the value of OCT for quantification and monitoring of the changes in comparison with other bioengineering methods was evaluated. Repeated measurements were performed in healthy volunteers after experimental induction of irritant contact dermatitis and in patients with psoriasis. In the OCT images, the thickness of the epidermis and the signal attenuation coefficient in the upper dermis were evaluated. The changes were compared with measurements of transepidermal water loss, hydration, skin colour and surface roughness, and with high-frequency ultrasound measurements. In irritant dermatitis and psoriasis, thickening of the epidermis was detected and could be monitored over time. The light scattering in the upper dermis was lower than in healthy skin. This was interpreted to be due to the inflammation and oedema, leading to a less-dense arrangement of the collagen fibres. The changes in the OCT images did not significantly correlate with the changes shown by the other methods. OCT is an interesting tool for investigation of inflammatory skin diseases. It is a simple method for determination of epidermal thickness and therefore provides, in addition to other methods, information on the severity of the disease and on treatment effects.Archives for Dermatological Research 07/2003; 295(2):50-5. · 2.71 Impact Factor
- [show abstract] [hide abstract]
ABSTRACT: Optical coherence tomography (OCT) is a new and promising diagnostic technique for investigation of skin tumours. We describe a method that makes evaluation and definition of specific morphologic structures of skin tumours via OCT more accurate. We investigated three patients with basal cell carcinoma and three patients with melanocytic nevi. Three-dimensional (3D) images were obtained from these skin tumours via OCT according to previously applied marks, which were tattooed with special histological marking dye after excision of the tumours. Corresponding to these marks, we investigated serial histological sections (haematoxylin&eosin staining). We could prove similar morphological structures both in OCT and histology. Due to tissue deformation, the compared measurements of structures like cell nests or epidermal thickness were slightly deviated. However, by this method we could prove similar tissue formations in OCT and histology. Due to the deformation by histological processing and slightly different sectioning levels, the comparison of histological pictures and OCT images seems difficult. Nevertheless, in two cases it was possible to demonstrate the same morphological structures with OCT imaging and histological investigation. Our method could play an important role for further evaluation of OCT images. We estimate better evaluation of OCT imaging using a 3D reconstruction method.Skin Research and Technology 08/2004; 10(3):169-73. · 1.41 Impact Factor
Assessment and Correction of Imaging Artifacts in
Skin Imaging using Fibre-based Optical Coherence
Yih Miin Liew1, Robert A. McLaughlin1, Andrea Curatolo1, and David D. Sampson1,2
1Optical+Biomedical Engineering Laboratory, School of Electrical, Electronic and Computer Engineering, M018
The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley 6009, Australia
2Centre for Microscopy, Characterisation & Analysis,
The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley 6009, Australia
Abstract Summary (35 words)
This study reports two types of imaging artifacts in 3D optical
coherence tomography images of human skin – intensity deficits and
geometrical distortion, and describes their reduction through the
application of refractive index matching media.
Keywords- Optical coherence tomography, skin imaging,
artifacts, index matching
Optical coherence tomography (OCT) is a high resolution,
optical in vivo imaging modality used in medical diagnostics
and research imaging. The working principle of OCT is
analogous to that of ultrasound ; however, instead of
acoustic waves, OCT employs broadband near infrared light to
probe biological tissue. The broadband light is delivered to the
tissue using a fibre-optic probe. Backscattered light from the
tissue is interfered with a reference beam with known optical
path length to provide precise optical gating of the tissue
microstructures. To date, a spatial resolution ranging from 2 to
20 microns is attainable with OCT.
Fibre-based OCT has been applied to the field of
dermatology for the assessment of skin diseases , tumours
, UV-induced skin alterations , skin characteristics , as
well as the efficacy of the laser treatment of port wine stain
OCT, in common with other imaging modalities, suffers
from imaging artifacts. Two dominant artifacts observed in
skin imaging are intensity and geometrical artifacts. Intensity
artifacts appear as multiple vertical streaks of artificially low
backscatter directly below the pits on the skin surface, as
shown in Fig. 1, causing the remapping of the surface
topography within the volume. This artifact masks the
subsurface structures and causes the appearance of remapped
extraneous features when viewing OCT en face images (i.e.,
images in the plane perpendicular to the light beam).
Geometrical artifacts are caused by changes in the optical
path length due to different proportions of tissue and air in
adjacent sections of the scan, and results in the artificial
displacement and shape distortion of subsurface structures.
OCT images of wrinkled skin, such as those on the arms, legs,
back of hand, eyelids and joints are commonly contaminated
with these artifacts. This artifact is illustrated in Fig. 4(A)
where a phantom sitting on a glass plate with a different
refractive index from air appears erroneously thick.
These artifacts were present in the OCT images of skin in
previous papers [2, 5, 7-9], but to our knowledge have not been
explicitly reported. This study addresses these two artifacts in
OCT, outlining possible causes and exploring their reduction
using two common refractive index-matching media – glycerol
and ultrasound gel.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A. OCT system
All OCT images in this study were acquired using a swept-
source frequency-domain OCT system (OCS1300SS, Thorlabs,
Figure 1. (A) A volumetric skin OCT image shown in 3 orthogonal planes
(cs: cross section). (B) Cross-sectional image (cs 1) with intensity artifacts
(arrows). (C)Surface render of the volumetric image. (D) En face image (cs 2)
with intensity artifacts.
USA). This system (Fig. 2) contains a broadband, high-speed
frequency swept laser source and a fibre-based (SMF-28)
Michelson interferometer with balanced detection. The light
source has a centre wavelength of 1325 nm and an average
light output power of 10 mW. The system’s axial and
transverse resolution is 12 µm and 15 µm, respectively, in air.
The handheld OCT probe contains the focusing optics, and can
be easily positioned to scan a range of anatomical locations. A
glass cover slip (thickness 0.17 mm) was secured to the
handheld probe so as to be positioned immediately adjacent to
B. Phantom Study
A range of skin-mimicking silicone phantoms were
fabricated and consisted of an imprint of a human inner
forearm skin surface, with scattering provided by either TiO2 or
Al2O3 particles (Sigma Aldrich, USA). 3D scans of the
phantom were acquired with three different setups: a bare
phantom exposed to air; the phantom coated with a layer of
100% glycerol; and the phantom coated with a layer of
ultrasound gel. The glass cover slip affixed to the OCT probe
was used to flatten the refractive index matching media
(glycerol or ultrasound gel).
The refractive index of the phantom material (prepared
separately as a thin layer on a glass slide), glycerol and
ultrasound gel was measured according to the method proposed
in . The result is shown in Table 1.
C. Human Subject Study
A similar location on the skin of the inner forearm of a
human volunteer was imaged. Three scans were acquired: bare
skin; with a coating of 100% glycerol; and with a coating of
ultrasound gel. A time gap of 3 hours was left between scans
with glycerol and ultrasound gel to allow the skin to recover
from any possible swelling caused by the medium.
OCT images were acquired with the same imaging protocol
as used for the phantom study.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
A. Phantom Study
The OCT images of the skin-mimicking phantom are
shown in Figs. 3 and 4. Intensity and geometrical artifacts
were predominantly found in the image acquired without the
use of index matching medium.
Intensity artifacts characteristically emerge at different
depths under the pits of the surface corrugations and they
broaden with depth. We believe these artifacts are caused by
the strong scattering of off-normal incident light on the skin of
higher refractive index than air (of approximately 1.43). The
corrugated patterning of the skin was observed to be important
in the appearance of these artifacts.
The application of glycerol and ultrasound gel reduced the
intensity artifacts, delaying their onset to greater depths as
illustrated in Fig. 3. The en face (at approximately 1.5 mm
(optical distance) beneath the phantom surface) and cross-
sectional images of the phantom indicate that the application of
100% glycerol resulted in higher reduction in the intensity
artifact as compared to the ultrasound gel.
THE REFRACTIVE INDEX OF SILICONE PHANTOM (TIO2), 100%
GLYCEROL AND ULTRASOUND GEL
Medium Refractive Index, n
Ultrasound gel 1.34
As OCT displays depth of the image in terms of optical
path length, the image of the subsurface structures is artificially
Figure 3. Left: En face (at depth of ≈ 1.5mm (optical distance) from surface);
and Right: cross-sectional images of the skin-mimicking phantom using TiO2
scatterers. (A) Bare phantom exposed to air. (B) Phantom coated with a 100%
glycerol layer. (C) Phantom coated with a layer of ultrasound gel.
Figure 2. Fibre-based swept source OCT system with handheld probe for
in vivo imaging.
Figure 4. Geometrical artifact compensation in a phantom using Al2O3
scatterers, sitting on a glass plate using index matching media, imaged from
above. (A) Bare phantom exposed to air (Arrow: Discontinuity in the
appearance of the glass slide due to light traveling through different amounts
of phantom and air). (B) Phantom coated with a 100% glycerol layer. (C)
Phantom coated with a layer of ultrasound gel.
displaced and distorted when light travels through different
amount of tissue and air. This distortion can potentially result
in discontinuities or deformations in the shape of structures
such as blood vessels. Such artifacts were observed beneath the
pits of the skin surface corrugations.
Fig. 4(A) demonstrates the geometrical artifact in OCT
imaging, in which the thickness of a phantom sitting on top of
a glass plate and the surface location of the glass plate appear
distorted (arrow). This distortion was due to the uneven
thickness of the phantom, which can be compensated using
index matching medium and a glass cover slip. This is shown
in Figs. 4(B) and (C).
B. Human Subject Study
Similar results were obtained from in vivo images of human
skin. A reduction in intensity and geometrical artifacts was
observed using both index-matching media.
Fig. 5 shows the en face images of the inner forearm skin at
approximately 500 µm (optical distance) below the skin
surface. Glycerol and ultrasound gel were shown to reduce the
intensity artifacts in skin by reducing extraneous lines
mimicking surface topography in the en face images. In
addition, it was observed that glycerol gave better optical
clearing  of the skin than ultrasound gel, allowing better
visualization of tissue in deeper layers. This is due to the close
matching of its refractive index to tissue.
Fig. 6(A) shows an artifact-contaminated image of the inner
forearm skin with blood vessels, and the corresponding images
using index-matching media. Both intensity and geometrical
artifacts were observed to be reduced with the use of index
matching media (Figs. 6(B,C)). Note the artificial discontinuity
(bend) in the blood vessel (labeled with an arrow). The
geometrical distortions of the blood vessels due to the sudden
change in the thickness of the epidermal layer (and, thus,
optical path length of light) were compensated using both
index matching media.
Despite the reduction in image artifacts, there are
complications in the use of glycerol and ultrasound gel. This
includes trapping of air bubbles within the refractive index
matching medium which can cause the introduction of other
artifacts, including shadowing by the air bubbles. Careful
sample preparation is required to minimize the occurrence of
such air bubbles.
Artifacts are detrimental to the correct interpretation and
quantification of subsurface structures of the skin using OCT.
We have shown that a refractive index-matching medium can
be used to reduce intensity and geometrical artifacts in OCT
images of skin. Glycerol and ultrasound gels were assessed
using both phantom and in vivo image acquisitions. They are
both effective in reducing geometrical artifacts. Glycerol was
shown to give a better reduction in the intensity artifacts and
allows better optical clearing of the sample as compared to
T. Gambichler, G. Moussa, M. Sand, D. Sand, P. Altmeyer, and K.
Hoffmann, "Applications of optical coherence tomography in
dermatology," J. Dermatol. Sci., vol. 40, pp. 85-94, 2005.
J. Welzel, M. Bruhns, and H. H. Wolff, "Optical coherence tomography
in contact dermatitis and psoriasis," Arch. Dermatol. Res., vol. 295, pp.
F. G. Bechara, T. Gambichler, M. Stucker, A. Orlikov, S. Rotterdam, P.
Altmeyer, and K. Hoffmann, "Histomorphologic correlation with routine
histology and optical coherence tomography," Skin Res. Technol., vol.
10, pp. 169-173, 2004.
T. Gambichler, S. Boms, M. Stüker, G. Moussa, A. Kreuter, M. Sand, D.
Sand, P. Altmeyer, and K. Hoffmann, "Acute skin alterations following
ultraviolet radiation investigated by optical coherence tomography and
histology," Arch. Dermatol. Res., vol. 297, pp. 218-225, 2005.
T. Gambichler, R. Matip, G. Moussa, P. Altmeyer, and K. Hoffmann,
"In vivo data of epidermal thickness evaluated by optical coherence
tomography: Effects of age, gender, skin type, and anatomic site," J.
Dermatol. Sci., vol. 44, pp. 145-152, Dec 2006.
J. S. Nelson, K. M. Kelly, Y. Zhao, and Z. Chen, "Imaging blood flow in
human port-wine stain in situ and in real time using optical doppler
tomography," Arch. Dermatol., vol. 137, pp. 741-744, 2001.
J. Welzel, C. Reinhardt, E. Lankenau, C. Winter, and H. H. Wolff,
"Changes in function and morphology of normal human skin: evaluation
using optical coherence tomography," Br. J. Dermatol., vol. 150, pp.
Figure 5. En face images of the inner forearm skin at approximately 500 µm
from the skin surface. (A) bare skin (B) with a coating of 100% glycerol;
and (C) with a coating of ultrasound gel. (Note: All 3 images were
approximately co-located. Arrows: artifacts caused by trapped air bubbles in
the index matching medium.)
Figure 6. Cross-sectional images of the inner forearm skin showing the
geometrical artifacts (solid arrows) and intensity artifacts (dashed arrows) in
scans of the skin through: air (A); glycerol (B); and ultrasound gel (C).
J. Welzel, "Optical coherence tomography in dermatology: a review,"
Skin Res. Technol., vol. 7, pp. 1-9, 2001.
M. C. Pierce, J. Strasswimmer, B. H. Park, B. Cense, and J. F. de Boer,
"Birefringence measurements in human skin using polarization-sensitive
optical coherence tomography," J. Biomed. Opt., vol. 9, p. 287, 2004.
 G. J. Tearney, M. E. Brezinski, J. F. Southern, B. E. Bouma, M. R. Hee,
and J. G. Fujimoto, "Determination of the refractive index of highly
scattering human tissue by optical coherence tomography," Opt. Lett,
vol. 20, pp. 2258-2260, 1995.
 Z. Mao, D. Zhu, Y. Hu, X. Wen, and Z. Han, "Influence of alcohols on
the optical clearing effect of skin in vitro," J. Biomed. Opt., vol. 13, pp.