Conference Paper

On the Goal Domain in the RM-ODP Enterprise Language: An Initial Appraisal Based on a Foundational Ontology

Comput. Sci. Dept., Fed. Univ. of Espirito Santo (UFES), Vitória, Brazil
DOI: 10.1109/EDOCW.2010.47 Conference: Enterprise Distributed Object Computing Conference Workshops (EDOCW), 2010 14th IEEE International
Source: IEEE Xplore


The “goal domain” addresses objectives in a broad scope ranging from high-level statements expressing the vision and mission of an organization (or community) to declarations of the results that must be achieved by business process execution. This paper reviews the support for the goal domain in ISO RM-ODP. We analyze the conceptualization for goals (objectives) in the reference model's Enterprise Viewpoint using a fragment of the Unified Foundational Ontology (UFO) that deals with some aspects of social reality and intentionality. The interpretation of the RM-ODP concepts in terms of this foundation may help to provide a sound underpinning for these concepts and support the identification of possible extensions of the reference model.

Download full-text


Available from: João Paulo A. Almeida, Apr 09, 2014
21 Reads
  • Source
    • "UFO has also been successfully used to design a language underlying a Knowledge Management Systems methodology [5] and to align Goals and Business Processes [6]. Finally, UFO has been employed with success in the analysis of alternative enterprise modeling standards and languages such as RM-ODP [7] and Archimate [8], ARIS [9], BPMN [10], REA [11], among others, In all these cases, the ontological approach has proven itself useful in clarifying the semantics, and consequently, the possible uses of the language's construct. This makes it much easier for the designer (novice or not) to apply the language in practice, once all ontological commitments have been made explicit. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The i* community has raised several main dialects and dozens of variations in the definition of the i* language. Differences may be found related not just to the representation of new concepts but to the very core of the i* language. If on the one hand this is caused by large adoption of the framework in the academic setting, on the other hand, it also poses some threats. For example, novices have trouble learning how to use the language, and besides these inconsistencies prevent i* from being largely adopted in business settings. Based on positive results from previous work related to conceptual modeling languages, we believe that foundational ontologies may present a promising solution for this problem. Foundational ontologies may help clarifying the semantics of core i* constructs and provide practical guidelines for their use. Last, they may serve as the basis to propose a normative definition of the framework. In this paper, we develop this idea, first by justifying the use of foundational ontologies and, in particular, the UFO ontology. Then, we raise some problems found in the i* literature. And then, we show the outcomes of adopting an ontological approach for the specific case of the i* framework. We focus here on one of the most characteristic i* construct, namely the means-end link.
    Research Challenges in Information Science (RCIS), 2012 Sixth International Conference on; 01/2012
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In our past work, we have shown that a number of theories from conceptual modeling and ontological analysis can be used to clarify the definitions of role-related and goal-related concepts in the RM-ODP [1,2]. This paper builds up on our earlier efforts by providing an ontology-based account for the notion of communities in the reference model's Enterprise Language [38]. We address issues regarding the composition of communities, the filling of roles in communities, the decomposition of a community's objective into sub-objectives (delegated to community members). The use of an ontology that deals with aspects of social reality and intentionality [30] plays an important role in this account, revealing the intentionality of communities and enterprise objects; the social relations between communities and enterprise objects in the community; the social relations between objects in the community; the social relations between communities; the normative character of a community's contract, etc. The analysis allows us to propose well-founded recommendations for clarifications and identify potential amendments to the standard as well as issues for further investigation.
    Computer Standards & Interfaces 03/2013; 35(3):257–268. DOI:10.1016/j.csi.2012.01.007 · 0.88 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This paper provides an editorial introduction to the current special issue on Open Distributed Processing. It looks back over the development of the ODP standards and at the way in which they have been used, and looks forward at the way current activities are progressing. It contains a broad bibliography covering ODP standards, related research work and application case studies.
    Computer Standards & Interfaces 03/2013; 35(3):247-256. DOI:10.1016/j.csi.2012.05.003 · 0.88 Impact Factor
Show more