Use and limits of three methods for assessing fish size spectra and fish abundance in two tropical man-made lakes

INRA, Station Hydrobiologie Lacustre, UMR CARRTEL, BP 511, 74203 Thonon les Bains, France
Fisheries Research (Impact Factor: 1.84). 02/2007; DOI: 10.1016/j.fishres.2006.10.005

ABSTRACT A comparative study, combining three different assessment methods (fish gillnet sampling, artisanal fisheries surveys and hydroacoustics) was conducted in Mali where two man-made reservoirs (Sélingué and Manantali) are particularly suited for investigating the impact of fishing effort on the fish assemblage. These two ecosystems have relatively similar areas, edaphic and environmental properties but are subjected to different levels of fishing exploitation (low at Manantali, high at Sélingué). The comparison is based on two indicator parameters: the abundance indices and the size spectra distributions, obtained by the three methods at two contrasting hydrological seasons (April and October). The results were compared first between the two seasons, and then between the two lakes. The present work is based on two main hypotheses: (1) that there is a higher fish abundance in October associated with smaller overall sizes, after spawning; (2) a lower abundance and smaller sizes in the Sélingué reservoir than in Manantali, because of the much higher fishing pressure in Sélingué. The relevance of each method to the selected indicators is discussed. On the one hand, the three methodologies on the whole gave similar conclusions and they also complement each other. On the other hand, some results do not match the hypotheses because of biases due to difficulties and technical limitations of each method in such ecosystems (shallow water with vegetation and stumps of former forests).


Available from: Raymond Laë, Apr 17, 2015
1 Follower
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The aim of this study was to quantify the fish fauna in the Three Gorges Dam (TGD) and assess the tendency for change as well as for any spatial and temporal distribution. Two types of echo-sounder equipment (HTI Model 241 and Simrad EY60) were used to detect the fish density and fish spatio-temporal distribution. Eight surveys were conducted between 2006 and 2010, with the results showing that fish abundance in the Three Gorges Reservoir (TGR) increased yearly from 15.5 to 123 ind./1000 m3, a change apparently correlated with the corresponding increase in the reservoir water level. Horizontally, fish density increased from the lower reaches to the upper reaches. Fish preferred inhabiting the area around the Zhongxian section during winter and the Chongqing section in spring. Vertically, fish density was highest in the lower layer, followed by the middle layer. The difference in fish density in different water layers observed in spring was not as evident as in the winter. Fish target strength throughout the eight investigations showed a skewed distribution with respect to fish size. The overall increasing tendency of fish density and the spatio-temporal distribution of fish species were closely related to the water level of the TGR during the impounding period. Other influencing factors included water flow rate, water depth, reservoir shape, habitat type, and protection policy.
    Journal of Applied Ichthyology 12/2013; 29(6). DOI:10.1111/jai.12370 · 0.90 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The present study analyses the distribution and abundance of Foblana alchichica, an atherinidae fish endemic to Lake Alchichica. Fish were sampled using hydroacoustic surveys, carrying out equidistant transect performed on a perpendicular grid that covered the entire surface of the lake on a seasonal basis to take into account the four hydrodynamic stages of Lake Alchichica. Results indicate that vertical distribution of fish varies in time and is limited by the availability of dissolved oxygen in deeper layers. Prey distribution and the zone in which reproduction occurs (i.e., the littoral) limit the horizontal distribution of the fish. Abundance of P. alchichica varied from 12,510 fish in early stratification up to 29,200 fish in the well-established stratification. Spatially, the average abundance in the littoral zone was 13,973±2,040 fish while in the pelagic zone abundance reached 7,088±1.395 fish. Density of F. alchichica fluctuated from 0.000015 individuals per m 3 in the pelagic zone during the early stratification to 0.019 individuals per m 3 in the littoral zone during the well-established stratification. Mean density estimates was 0.009±0.002 individuals per mS. Hydroacoustic technique allowed understanding effectively fish density and distribution. These values are lower than those found in comparable environments and highlight the importance of the littoral zone and consequently the water level reduction, for the conservation of the species in the ecosystem.
    Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Science 06/2011; 6624:624-632632. DOI:10.3923/jfas.2011.624.632
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Marine Protected Areas (MPAs), in addition to their important role in the conservation of critical habitats and vulnerable species, are now also used in a context of ecosystem-based fisheries management. The aim of this study was to assess the observed changes in the fish population structure in the years following a fishing ban. The experiment took place in the Bamboung bolong, a small bay in the Sine Saloum estuary in Senegal, West Africa. The protection of this zone was undertaken with local fishermen support, and a formal MPA was created in 2004. The survey of the fish assemblages was initiated in 2003, the year before the fishing ban, and went on until 2007, with 12 sampling sites being monitored three times per year. In this paper, we describe and analyze the evolution of the fish assemblage during this five years' experimental period. Some changes have been highlighted on which the effect of the fishing ban was shown. After the fishing ban, an increase of total biomass and of maximal fish length has been registered. In the same time, the number of species has increased and the percentage of large and/or iconic species targeted by fishing has also increased. The community structure has been modified, with more small fish, more big fish (new large species and more large individuals in the original species) and fewer medium sized fish. The contribution of marine affinity species has increased in depend of the estuarine part of the assemblage. Finally, the trophic structure has been modified with an overall increase of the mean trophic level, resulting from an increase of the percentage of generalist or piscivorous predators and a sharp decrease of herbivorous and detritivorous low trophic level species. Marine predators which numbers and size were reduced by fisheries are again important components of the system. We argue that despite the intrinsic variability of the tropical estuarine environments, the introduction of a total ban on fishing in such estuarine zones can substantially improve the health status of the fish assemblage.
    Ocean & Coastal Management 11/2014; 100:74–85. DOI:10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2014.08.009 · 1.77 Impact Factor