The dynamics of mid-ocean ridge hydrothermal systems: Splitting plumes and fluctuating vent temperatures

Department of Earth Science & Engineering, Imperial College London, RSM Building, Exhibition Road, London, SW7 2AZ
Earth and Planetary Science Letters (Impact Factor: 4.73). 05/2006; 245(1-2):218-231. DOI: 10.1016/j.epsl.2006.02.044


We present new, accurate numerical simulations of 2D models resembling hydrothermal systems active in the high-permeability axial plane of mid-ocean ridges and show that fluid flow patterns are much more irregular and convection much more unstable than reported in previous simulation studies. First, we observe the splitting of hot, rising plumes. This phenomenon is caused by the viscous instability at the interface between hot, low-viscosity fluid and cold, high-viscosity fluid. This process, known as Taylor–Saffman fingering could potentially explain the sudden extinguishing of black smokers. Second, our simulations show that for relatively moderate permeabilities, convection is unsteady resulting in transiently varying vent temperatures. The amplitude of these fluctuations typically is 40 °C with a period of decades or less, depending on the permeability. Although externally imposed events such as dike injections are possible mechanisms, they are not required to explain temperature variations observed in natural systems. Our results also offer a simple explanation of how seismic events cause fluctuating temperatures: Earthquake-induced permeability-increase shifts the hydrothermal system to the unsteady regime with accompanying fluctuating vent temperatures. We demonstrate that realistic modelling of these high-Rayleigh number convection systems does not only require the use of real fluid properties, but also the use of higher order numerical methods capable of handling high-resolution meshes. Less accurate numerical solutions smear out sharp advection fronts and thereby artificially stabilize the system.

Download full-text


Available from: Dim Coumou,
  • Source
    • ") and numerical models (Kaminski and Jaupart, 2003; Homma et al., 2006). Similar geometry is often associated with jets originating from submarine chimneys that exhale hot hydrothermal fluids with high velocities into relatively colder oceanic water (Fig. 1a) (Coumou et al., 2006). Other common examples of natural plumes range from large-scale meteorological plumes rising over the desert to explosive volcanic eruptions or saline plumes descending from melting sea ice. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Using multi-phase numerical experiments based on the Volume of fluid (VOF) methods we show the ascent behavior of a fluid injected into another immiscible fluid with higher viscosity. Our VOF models reveal that the injected fluid forms jets characterized by a large head trailing to a slender tail, which do not break up, but ascend in two principal modes, Mode 1: continuous and Mode 2: pulsating. In Mode 1, their heads grow continuously either by volume expansion, forming balloon-shaped geometry (Mode 1a) or by curling, forming mushroom-shaped geometry (Mode 1b). In contrast, Mode 2 jets ascend in pulses, forming multiple heads, leading to pinched-off geometry. In this study we show the viscosity ratio (R) between the injecting and the ambient fluids as a crucial parameter in controlling the ascent modes, and provide an estimate of critical R for the Mode 1-2 transition under varying fluid injection rates (non-dimensionalized as Reynolds number, Re). From the entrainment velocity field we explain that the transition of continuous to pulsating process results from the flow convergence at several locations along the upwelling direction. We have also discussed the effects of buoyancy on the ascent modes in case of plumes.
    International Journal of Multiphase Flow 07/2014; 63. DOI:10.1016/j.ijmultiphaseflow.2014.02.007 · 2.06 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Hydrothermal vents are highly dynamic ecosystems, characterized by great spatial and temporal instability. Super-heated fluid emitted from hydrothermal vents can reach temperatures of $400 1C, and the cooling effects of surrounding seawater create acute thermal gradients (Coumou et al., 2006). Additionally, the venting of fluids is often unstable and sudden bursts of hot vent fluid are common, meaning vents display great thermal heterogeneity (Desbruy eres et al., 2000; Hourdez and Lallier, 2007). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The hydrothermal vent shrimp Mirocaris fortunata is commonly exposed to acute thermal gradients and rapid fluctuations in water temperature. The shallow-water shrimp Palaemonetes varians experiences less acute but similar magnitude fluctuations in its thermal regime. Acute respiratory response to temperature shock, and temperature preference was assessed for both species. Oxygen consumption rates were assessed across the natural temperature range reported for M. fortunata. Rates increased with temperature for both species. P. varians had a significantly higher rate of oxygen consumption than M. fortunata at all temperatures except 4°C. The rate of increase in oxygen consumption with increasing temperature was also significantly greater for P. varians. M. fortunata selected a significantly higher temperature than P. varians. Mirocaris fortunata maintains its metabolism at a more stable rate, which is likely an adaptation to acute changes in temperatures occurring at hydrothermal vents.
    Deep Sea Research Part II Topical Studies in Oceanography 11/2012; 92(in press). DOI:10.1016/j.dsr2.2012.12.003 · 2.19 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "In contrast, seafloor spreading at a fast spreading ridge where the crust moves at half rates of 50 km/Myr, so that 5 km of lower crustal flow away from the ridge axis occur on a timescale of ~ 10 5 yrs. Models of hydrothermal processes tend to use a model time step of less than a year and are typically limited in size to a crustal thickness-scale (Coumou et al., 2006) while numerical experiments describing the process of crustal accretion and subaxial mantle flow (Morgan and Chen, 1993b) need to model thermal evolution over timescales of several million years. Our model aims to simultaneous resolve the development of hydrothermal convection cells while solving for crustal and mantle flow associated with seafloor spreading. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The genesis of oceanic crust at intermediate to fast spreading ridges occurs by the crystallization of mantle melts accumulated in at least one shallow melt lens situated below the ridge axis. Seismic reflection data suggest that the depth of this melt lens is inversely correlated with spreading rate and thereby magma supply. The heat released in it by crystallization and melt injection is removed by a combination of hydrothermal cooling and diffusion. Due to the different time scales of hydrothermal cooling and crustal accretion, numerical models have so far focused on only one of the two processes. Here we present the results from a coupled model that solves simultaneously for crustal accretion and hydrothermal cooling. Our approach resolves both processes within one 2D finite-element model that self-consistently solves for crustal, mantle, and hydrothermal flow. The formation of new oceanic crust is approximated as a gabbro glacier, in which the entire lower crust crystallizes in one shallow melt lens.We find that the depth of the melt lens and the shape of hot (potentially molten) lower crust are highly dependent on the ridge permeability structure. The predicted depth of the melt lens is primarily controlled by the permeability at the ridge axis, whereas the off-axis permeability determines the width of hot lower crust. A detailed comparison of the modeling results with observed locations of the melt lens at intermediate to fast spreading ridges shows that only a relatively narrow range of crustal permeabilities is consistent with observations. In addition, we find significant deviations between models that resolve or parameterize hydrothermal cooling: the predicted crustal thermal structures show major differences for models that predict the same melt lens location. This illustrates the importance of resolving hydrothermal flow in simulations of crustal accretion.
    Earth and Planetary Science Letters 11/2011; 311(3-4). DOI:10.1016/j.epsl.2011.09.018 · 4.73 Impact Factor
Show more