Facilitator versus preceptor: Which offers the best support to undergraduate nursing students?

School of Nursing & Midwifery, Faculty of Sciences, Engineering & Health, CQUniversity Australia, Bruce Highway, Rockhampton Q 4702, Australia.
Nurse education today (Impact Factor: 0.91). 01/2012; DOI: 10.1016/j.nedt.2011.12.005
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION: There is an abundance of literature regarding factors that influence student learning within the clinical environment. Within this discourse, there is a paucity of research on the impact of supervision models on the learning support needs of students. This paper presents the results of research that focused on nursing students' perceptions about the effectiveness of the support they received during their work integrated learning (WIL) experience. BACKGROUND: The majority of students placed within health care facilities are in groups. The group model incorporates a facilitator who supervises the students who are placed across a number of wards. At the ward level students are then assigned a Registered Nurse (RN) who is their mentor. This occurs on a shift by shift basis. Another model of clinical supervision involves preceptorship. This approach is via a one-on-one supervision of students. Within the preceptorship model, students are supervised by a RN who is responsible for supporting them during their WIL experience and for completing their assessment. METHODS: This study compared two models of clinical supervision to better understand the learning support needs as perceived by undergraduate nursing students during their WIL experience. Survey method using a self reporting online questionnaire developed by the researchers was used to collect data. RESULTS: 159 undergraduate nursing students enrolled in a Bachelor level programme of study completed the on-line survey. When comparing the two models of supervision, students supervised within the facilitator model were statistically more likely to be challenged to reflect, think, build on existing skills and knowledge and to problem-solve issues. Notably, all factors integral to RN education. Overall, students considered the quality of support to be the most important facet of supervision. CONCLUSIONS: The findings of this study demonstrate that the facilitator model is the better approach for the development of critical thinking, but both models enable the development of a student's professional identity and the development of their role within nursing. This highlights the significance of clinical experiences during undergraduate nursing education.

1 Bookmark
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The concept of clinical supervision to facilitate the clinical education environment in undergraduate nursing students is well discussed within the literature. Despite the many models of clinical supervision described within the literature there is a lack of clear guidance and direction which clinical supervision model best suits the clinical learning environment for undergraduate nursing students since the formation of Health Workforce Australia. This paper reviews the five clinical supervision models described by Health Workforce Australia and demonstrates that there is clear evidence to support that the facilitator-preceptor and dedicated-education unit models are two models of clinical supervision to best support the clinical learning environment.
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The transition of nursing education from the hospital setting to the university sector over recent decades has opened dialogue about who is guiding the development of nursing students’ professional identity. In addition, there is ongoing debate over real or perceived gaps between nursing student learning in the university and the clinical area, how this translates into professional behaviours and how well students make the transition between the two settings. This paper presents the findings of an integrative literature review into the topic of role modelling in undergraduate nursing education. This review was conducted to identify and appraise research findings about role modelling of professional behaviours for undergraduate nursing students. Literature reviewed from 2000 onwards assesses what is currently known about role modelling of undergraduate nursing students A systematic search of the databases of CINAHL, Scopus and PubMed from 2000 onwards resulted in the selection of 33 articles for deeper analysis. Two clear themes emerged from the literature, the first relating to nurse clinicians as role models for students during clinical placements and the second relating to nurse academics as role models in the academic setting. Findings from this integrative literature review show an imbalance in the recognition of the role modelling of professional behaviours in the clinical versus the academic setting. Nurses in academic settings have more contact with the students over their period of study and as such, the significance of nurse academics as student role models requires further investigation.
    Nurse education today 01/2013; · 0.91 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The aim of this study was to deepen the understanding of student nurses' processes of understanding and becoming nurses. The study is phenomenological-hermeneutic in design, comprising data from three focus group interviews in two Scandinavian countries. The process of student nurses' understanding and becoming a nurse emerged as a hermeneutical movement. A caring student-preceptor relationship and a growth-promoting preception in a supportive and inclusive environment provide the frame within which the movement happens. The movement towards understanding and becoming is initiated as students, based on their level of knowledge, are given responsibility. In order to fulfil the responsibility imposed on them, students take their entire repertoire of knowledge into consideration. By tying these threads together, they found the basis for conscious action, and care is provided according to what the current situation requires. The experiences obtained are reflected on and integrated with earlier knowledge, which leads to enhanced understanding. Students form a new base to stand on. They show increased readiness for still more responsibility and action. This movement towards deeper understanding and becoming affects the students also ethically and deepens their ethical awareness. When one loop of understanding and becoming is closed the process continues by passing into a new loop. This movement could be described as a hermeneutical spiral consisting of interconnected loops taking the students further and deeper in their process of understanding and becoming a nurse. The student-preceptor relationship and the ethos permeating it are decisive for students' learning both epistemologically and ontologically. Responsibility is the catalyst in students' understanding and becoming both intellectually and ethically. Understanding and becoming are ongoing processes of appropriation, thus altering students both professionally and personally. Understanding and becoming can be perceived as the hearth of the matter in nurse education.
    Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences 03/2014; · 0.89 Impact Factor


Available from
May 22, 2014