Fostering design for avoiding small parts in commonly used objects

Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority, Region Southwest, PO Box 3000, 3330 DC Zwijndrecht, The Netherlands.
International journal of pediatric otorhinolaryngology (Impact Factor: 1.19). 03/2012; 76 Suppl 1:S57-60. DOI: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2012.02.014
Source: PubMed


Injuries due to the accidental ingestion or aspiration of small parts have became a matter of interest in the last 30 years, focusing on the relationship between a proper prevention and the diminished frequency of occurrences. Small parts in commonly used objects represent a large sector of potential danger, taking explicit mouthing behavior of children in the first four years of life. In this paper the intent is to show the current situation of design projects and legislation around the world, meant to avoid the casual accidents due to manufacturing reasons. Proposed process and quality control standards seek to eliminate production errors and control materials to avoid deviation from the design.
The present study draws its data from the Susy Safe registry, a European Commission co-funded project started in February 2005, whose aim is to establish an international registry of cases of Foreign Bodies (FB) injuries in children aged 0-14 years. Information collected from the data base concern age and gender of the child, location, shape, volume, consistency and elipticity of the foreign body, any complication occurred, hospitalization, and behavioral aspects linked to the injury, like the supervision of the parents or the activity concomitant to the injury. Cases are prospectively collected using the Susy Safe system from 06/2005; moreover, also information regarding past consecutive cases available in each center adhering to the project have been entered in the Susy Safe Registry.
Data evidenced that the majority of small parts related injuries are related to stationery. The majority of objects (56.7%), were located in the nose, followed by the ears (31.5%). The distribution on incidence of FB injuries by age class shows that the majority of injuries due to small parts in common objects occurred in children older than >3 years. Male and female were affected with the same frequency when concerning the nose, while all other locations showed a higher frequency in males. Data suggested that hospitalization occurred in 32% of those who compiled the form, resulting in complication just in 16% of injured. Although the most frequent location needing hospitalization was the tracheobronchial tree, the most frequent location showing complication was the nose, 80.3% of the complications, having an infection as most frequent outcome. In children younger than 1 year median volume reached 333.62 mm(3), in children between 1 and 2 years, median volume was 81.12 mm(3), in older children (>3 years) it showed 37.68 mm(3). The same considerations can be seen for the ellipticity, where the median ellipticity was 2.79 in children <1 year, while it was 1.94 in children between 1 and 2 years, and 1.17 in the older ones. Consistency is similar for all age classes, stressing that rigid small parts were those more involved in injuries with foreign bodies. Behavioral aspects pointed out that the 80% of children were playing before the accident, and 65.3% were under adults' supervision. Adult presence resulted associated to the absence of complication, with a p-value of 0.04.
The study stresses the importance of primary prevention, seen as the active care of adults toward children manipulating foreign bodies potentially dangerous. This presence may not avoid the event, but in case of FBs aspiration, ingestion, insertion or inhalation, it could be the main factor leading to fewer complications.

1 Read
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Aim: To determine the utility of X-ray in identifying non-metallic foreign body (FB) and assess inter-radiologist agreement in identifying non-metal FB. Methods: Focus groups of nurses, fellows, and attending physicians were conducted to determine commonly ingested objects suitable for inclusion. Twelve potentially ingested objects (clay, plastic bead, crayon, plastic ring, plastic army figure, glass bead, paperclip, drywall anchor, eraser, Lego™, plastic triangle toy, and barrette) were embedded in a gelatin slab placed on top of a water-equivalent phantom to simulate density of a child's abdomen. The items were selected due to wide availability and appropriate size for accidental pediatric ingestion. Plain radiography of the embedded FBs was obtained. Five experienced radiologists blinded to number and types of objects were asked to identify the FBs. The radiologist was first asked to count the number of items that were visible then to identify the shape of each item and describe it to a study investigator who recorded all responses. Overall inter-rater reliability was analyzed using percent agreement and κ coefficient. We calculated P value to assess the probability of error involved in accepting the κ value. Results: Fourteen objects were radiographed including 12 original objects and 2 duplicates. The model's validity was supported by clear identification of a radiolucent paperclip as a positive control, and lack of identification of plastic beads (negative control) despite repeated inclusion. Each radiologist identified 7-9 of the 14 objects (mean 8, 67%). Six unique objects (50%) were identified by all radiologists and four unique objects (33%) were not identified by any radiologist (plastic bead, Lego™, plastic triangle toy, and barrette). Identification of objects that were not present, false-positives, occurred 1-2 times per radiologist (mean 1.4). An additional 17% of unique objects were identified by less than half of the radiologists. Agreement between radiologists was considered almost perfect (kappa 0.86 ± 0.08, P < 0.0001). Conclusion: We demonstrate potential non-identification of commonly ingested non-metal FBs in children. A registry for radiographic visibility of ingested objects should be created to improve clinical decision-making.
    05/2014; 3(2):14-8. DOI:10.5409/wjcp.v3.i2.14