Conference Paper

Using Card Sorts for Understanding Website Information Architectures: Technological, Methodological and Cultural Issues.

Conference: Human-Computer Interaction - INTERACT 2011 - 13th IFIP TC 13 International Conference, Lisbon, Portugal, September 5-9, 2011, Proceedings, Part IV
Source: DBLP

ABSTRACT The card sort technique has many uses in HCI research and practice. Card sorts have traditionally been conducted with physical cards but now programs are available for this task. It is unclear if results from an online version of this technique are as reliable as the "oncard" version. This paper presents a study comparing oncard and online versions of the card sort technique for card set reflecting the information architecture (IA) of two website domains (museum and news sites). No differences were found between the two versions. However, the online version took significantly longer for participants than the oncard version, particularly for non-native English speakers. The card sort technique was also able to reveal cultural differences between mental models of British, Chinese and Indian participants of the IAs of both museum and news websites and showed that all participants have mental models that differ substantially from the typical IAs of websites in these domains.

Download full-text


Available from: Helen L. Petrie, Jun 23, 2015
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Information architecture (IA) has become an important research area within the field of human computer interaction. The growing interest has led to the realization of the need to have validated methods for constructing website IA. Past practice of IA reflected the inclination towards using intuitive mapping of the website builder’s mental model. This paper reports the work that explored on the usability of using the KJ method to categorize and prioritize halal food information labels for the structural design of information space of websites whose content is rich with information on halal. A group of participants consisting of knowledgeable halal information consumers took part in this KJ method exercise to generate a halal hierarchical classification system. A prototype of a halal website using the classification obtained was constructed and tested for its usability and compared to the usability of an existing website for halal information portal. The results of the testing showed that the website IA from the KJ method generated classification produced better results than the existing website of existing halal portal.
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Dealing with the overwhelming daily amount of online information is perhaps the biggest challenge faced by all computer users, whether they are novices or experienced professionals. How, where and when to store information sources, such as websites, is becoming increasingly difficult as people spend more of their life online and use the internet in all aspects of their lives. Our survey of 202 internet users found that although 85% of the participants regularly use the favorites (bookmarks) function, 73% still have trouble finding a website that they have recently visited. Whether the strategy is to bookmark in a single massive list and use the search tool, or to bookmark into folders and sub-folders several levels deep, appears to make very little difference. This research proposes a contrarian approach, giving users a highly structured favorites (bookmarks) schema using only two levels, consisting of four main headings and 12 sub-headings. An open card sorting task was used to validate the utility of such an approach. The results and their impact towards a future user-based knowledge structure are presented in this paper.
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Designing intuitive interfaces for rural African users requires us to understand the users' conceptual model. We acknowledge differences in categorization approaches based on cultural factors, among others. In the absence of comprehensive literature and theories, we explore card sorting as a means to derive a local categorization of interface objects for one of our prototypes. Results indicate a locational-relational categorization scheme among Herero elders in Namibia.
    14th IFIP TC13 Conference on Human-Computer Interaction; 09/2013