Article

Mechanical agitation of very dilute antiserum against IgE has no effect on basophil staining properties.

Department of Molecular Cell Biology, State University of Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Experientia 06/1992; 48(5):504-8. DOI: 10.1007/BF01928175
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT A previously reported effect of mechanically agitated dilutions of antiserum raised against IgE was investigated using the loss of metachromatic staining properties of human basophil leukocytes as a model. A series of 24 blind experiments was performed in which we determined the number of toluidine blue-stainable basophils after incubating with vortexed or non-vortexed dilutions of anti-IgE. Tenfold serial dilutions were used, in the range 10(21) to 10(30) (6.6 x 10(-26) to 6.6 x 10(-35) M anti-IgE). We found no evidence for a different effect of strongly agitated dilutions, compared to dilutions made with minimal physical agitation. In fact, in our hands no effect of extreme dilutions was shown at all. We conclude that the effect of extreme dilutions of anti-IgE, reported by Davenas et al., needs further clarification and that in this process the reproducibility of results between experimenters should be carefully determined.

0 Bookmarks
 · 
53 Views
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: La Homeopatía se basa en principios y un sistema de conocimientos diferentes a los que apoyan al modelo biomédico convencional: este conflicto epistemológico es el motivo fundamental que explica por qué la Homeopatía es tan difícil de acep­tar por el razonamiento científico de nuestros días. Para legitimar la Homeopatía según las normas de este último, la investigación deberá confirmar la validez de sus preceptos básicos: el principio de similitud terapéutica, la experimentación de los medicamentos en personas saludables, la prescripción individualizada y el uso de altas diluciones. En consecuencia, la investigación básica debe proporcionar datos y modelos experimentales para corroborar estos supuestos básicos, mien­tras que los ensayos clínicos tienen por objeto confirmar la eficacia y efectividad de la Homeopatía en el tratamiento de la enfermedad. Este artículo aborda el modelo epistemológico de la Homeopatía sobre sus principios básicos con los datos resultantes de los diferentes campos de la investigación experimental moderna y apoya su uso terapéutico en los resultados de los ensayos clínicos disponibles. A este respecto, el principio de la individualiza­ción del tratamiento es la condición sine qua non para hacer operativa la similitud terapéutica y, en consecuencia, para exponer la eficacia y la efectividad clínica del tratamiento homeopático.
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Background: Discuss the homeopathic research initiatives, difficulties and proposals before the modern scientific rationality and the homeopathic epistemology. Methods: After extensive bibliographical investigation, the several researches were clustered according to the homeopathic presuppositions, confirming if the inherent premises to the model were respected in the several studies outlines. Results: In spite of the reduced number of works of satisfactory methodological quality, evidences that corroborate the foundations and the viability of the homeopathic therapeutics exist, being necessary an increment in the future research, so that we have definitive conclusions to the method questioning. Conclusions: Presenting different characteristics from those used by the conventional scientific paradigm, the research projects in homeopathy should value the peculiarities of the system, incorporating changes to contemplate both forms of thinking. RESUMO Objetivo: Discutir as iniciativas, as dificuldades e as propostas da pesquisa em homeopatia perante a racionalidade científica moderna e a epistemologia homeopática. Métodos: Após extenso levantamento bibliográfico, as diversas pesquisas foram agrupadas segundo os pressupostos homeopáticos, verificando se as premissas inerentes ao modelo foram respeitadas nos diversos desenhos de estudos. Resultados: Apesar do reduzido número de trabalhos de qualidade metodológica satisfatória, existem evidências que corroboram os fundamentos e a viabilidade da terapêutica homeopática, sendo necessário um incremento na pesquisa futura, a fim de que tenhamos conclusões definitivas acerca dos questionamentos que permeiam o método. Conclusões: Apresentando características distintas daquelas empregadas pelo paradigma científico convencional, os projetos de pesquisa em homeopatia devem valorizar as peculiaridades do sistema, incorporando mudanças que venham a contemplar ambas formas de pensar.
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The database HomBRex (Homeopathy Basic Research experiments) was established in 2002 to provide an overview of the basic research already done on homeopathy (http://www.carstens-stiftung.de/hombrex). By this means, it facilitates the exploration of the Similia Principle and the working mechanism of homeopathy. Since 2002, the total number of experiments listed has almost doubled. The current review reports the history of basic research in homeopathy as evidenced by publication dates and origin of publications. In July 2013, the database held 1868 entries. Most publications were reported from France (n = 267), followed by Germany (n = 246) and India (n = 237). In the last ten years, the number of publications from Brazil dramatically increased from n = 13 (before 2004) to n = 164 (compared to n = 251 published in France before 2004, and n = 16 between 2004 and 2013). The oldest database entry was from Germany (1832).
    Homeopathy: the journal of the Faculty of Homeopathy 07/2014; 103(3):193-7. DOI:10.1016/j.homp.2014.01.001 · 1.13 Impact Factor