Postmodernism, health and illness.

Retreat Hospital, York, England.
Journal of Advanced Nursing (Impact Factor: 1.53). 02/1996; 23(1):201-5. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.1996.tb03153.x
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT This paper examines the value of drawing on ideas from poststructuralism and postmodernism in an attempt to understand the relationship between health, culture and society. Medical and professional discourses have come under increasing criticism for being uncaring, stigmatizing and disempowering. This paper supports a postmodernist approach which allows analysis of the fabrication of 'health', 'illness' and 'patient' subjectivity and the effect of the inscription on the body. It is suggested that health care professionals need to be more reflexive about their own knowledge claims and to resist the discursive practices which disempower and reduce choice.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Aim To present an adaptation of interpretive interactionism that incorporates and honours feminist values and principles. Background Interpretive interactionism as described by Denzin can be useful when examining interactive processes. It is especially useful when events affect turning points in people's lives. When issues of power and power imbalances are of interest, a critical post-structural lens may be of use to the researcher. The authors planned to examine the interactions between midwives and women at the 'epiphaneal' points of decision making during second-stage labour. It became clear that it was necessary to honour and thus incorporate feminist principles and values in their methodology. Data sources This paper draws on a recently completed PhD project to demonstrate the application of post-structural feminist interpretive interactionism. Twenty six midwives representing each state and territory across Australia who were representative of every model of midwifery care offered in Australia were interviewed to gauge their experiences of what they believed represented good and poor case examples of decision making during second-stage labour. Review methods The authors critique the philosophical underpinnings of interpretive interactionism, and then modify these to acknowledge and incorporate post-structural and feminist ideologies. Discussion Interpretive interactionism is a useful methodology when the research question is best addressed by examining interactional processes and the meanings people make of them, especially if these occur at turning points in people's lives. Interpretive interactionism methodology can and should be improved by taking account of issues of power, feminism and post-structural values. Conclusion Post-structural feminist interpretative interactionism has much to offer healthcare researchers who want to develop methodologically robust findings. Implications for practice/research Post-structural feminist interpretive interactionism enables the researcher to be more cognisant of the complex social political and historical context of midwifery. Researchers using feminist and post-structural ideologies will enhance research findings when these tools are applied consciously and reflexively.
    Nurse researcher 01/2013; 21(1):14-22.
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: To better understand breastfeeding experiences among employed Thai mothers, descriptive study was employed and multiple triangulation were used. Qualitative methods were more suitable to provide an understanding of mothersû decisions and their infant feeding experiences, and to discover variables that influence infant feeding practice. Quantitative methods provided important data about variables among employed mothers that could be analyzed to explore relationships. The purpose of this article is to demonstrate how to apply combining qualitative and quantitative approaches in research on breastfeeding experiences. Issues related to the rationale and process of the study, the specific data collection and analysis will be dealt with in turn. In conclusion, combining qualitative and quantitative approaches provided a more comprehensive picture about the people and the research questions under study, and offered the benefits from each approach in terms of confirmation and completeness. Decisions were needed about the level of depth and breadth of the study in keeping with the nature of the topic, the research questions and the research environment. Using both qualitative and quantitative approaches facilitated those decisions.
    Thai journal of nursing research. 12/2004; 8(4):294-308.
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Within the profession of occupational therapy there has been a long‐standing tendency to classify a person's occupations according to set and concrete categories. Such perception is typical of the modern era. This article addresses the validity of categorizing occupation according to performance areas, in the world of the elderly. The story of an elderly lady's visit to the supermarket provides the backdrop for a theoretical discussion regarding the multiple levels of function and meaning of occupation, particularly for the elderly. The story is examined in relation to concepts of classification according to performance areas. On this basis, the relevance and therefore the validity of such classification in the world of elders’ occupations is questioned. In their conclusion, the authors suggest that readers approach the issue of occupations and the elderly in the spirit of postmodernism, a framework more suitable