The importance of social comparisons for high levels of subjective quality of life in chronic schizophrenic patients.

Centre for Psychiatry, Justus Liebig University, Giessen, Germany.
Quality of Life Research (Impact Factor: 2.86). 02/2000; 9(5):481-9. DOI: 10.1023/A:1008938011554
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT In schizophrenic patients, quality of life (QoL) studies often find high levels of general life satisfaction and satisfaction in various life domains despite deprived living conditions. Therefore, the usefulness of QoL as an outcome indicator has been questioned. Since social comparison processes have been postulated to be related to the level of satisfaction, this hypothesis was analysed empirically by the present study in schizophrenic patients. Satisfaction and social comparisons of 148 schizophrenic inpatients and 66 mentally healthy controls were examined with regard to the domains 'health' and 'family' by means of a standardised interview. The schizophrenic patients had a history of either long-term (n = 75) or short-term (n = 73) restricted and deprived living conditions. Long-term patients showed significantly higher satisfaction levels than short-term patients. They compared themselves predominantly laterally or downwards with fellow inpatients. Significant relationships between the direction of social comparisons and satisfaction ratings were found in all three samples. Social comparisons proved to be important for the level of satisfaction in schizophrenic patients. Results indicate that experiences of restricted and deprived living conditions induce accommodation processes and response-shifts that should be taken into account in the interpretation of quality-of-life data.

  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Abstract Not only chronic mental disease, but also psycho-social factors limit the quality of life (QoL) of mentally ill persons. From three theoretical explanation models of QoL — the medical model, labeling theory, and stress process model — we deduced three hypotheses. To test our hypotheses, we re-analysed data from the study “Social integration and quality of life of mentally ill people”. Data were derived from structured interviews with 305 in-patients in psychiatric institutions in the Canton of Zurich (Switzerland), and completed with few informations from their doctors’ files. Various QoL dimensions entered the statistical analyses as dependent variables. Results indicate varied explanation power of the models under investigation depending on the dimension of QoL: psychic symptoms highly influence the health-related QoL, but have only small effects on social and material QoL. Social as well as material QoL are strongly influenced by social support as well as, though to a lesser extent, by life stress events. Chronification of mental illness and perceived discrimination because of the mental disease indirectly affect QoL through reduced social support and increased psychic symptoms. From our results we conclude that social integration and rehabilitation of mentally ill people require a bio-psycho-social treatment approach.
    Östereichische Zeitschrift für Soziologie 08/2002; 27(4).
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Im Rahmen der Entwicklung von Kriterien zur Beurteilung der Qualität psychiatrischer Behandlung gewann in den letzten 20 Jahren die subjektive Perspektive der Betroffenen eine immer stärkere Bedeutung (Kilian/Angermeyer 1999; Kilian/Becker 2006, 2007; Lehman/Possidente/Hawker 1986). Mit dem Konzept der subjektiven Lebensqualität wurde dabei der Versuch unternommen, sowohl die psychischen und körperlichen als auch die materiellen und sozialen Aspekte psychischer Erkrankung zu berücksichtigen (Kilian 2006; Kilian/Angermeyer 1999). Gleichzeitig setzt sich bei Experten und Betroffenen die Überzeugung durch, dass eine Abkehr von einer primär defizit- und die Hinwendung zu einer stärker ressourcenorientierten Betrachtung psychischer Erkrankung notwendig ist (Deutsche Gesellschaft für Psychiatrie 2006; Hamann/Leucht/Kissling 2003; Prins 2007). Begriffe wie Empowerment oder Befähigung stehen dabei für ein Versorgungskonzept, welches nicht allein darauf abzielt, krankheitsbedingte Beeinträchtigungen zu kompensieren, sondern versucht, vorhandene Kompetenzen zur Bewältigung krankheitsbedingter Beeinträchtigungen und zu einer eigenständigen Lebensführung zu stärken (Bellamy/Mowbray 1998; Byrne et al. 1999; Chamberlin 1997; Corrigan et al. 1999; Corrigan 2002; Finfgeld 2004; Fisher 1994; McLean 1995; McLean 2000; Stromwell/Hurdle 2003).
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Individual quality of life (QOL) is a critical foundation of stable and cohesive societies. This research examines QOL among Iowa farmers, who as a group have seen their numbers decline precipitously over the past decades as the farm economy has undergone major restructuring processes. Farm families are nested in rural communities, many of which have also experienced persistent population loss and economic decline over the same period. A multilevel modeling approach is employed to examine determinants of subjective QOL over time, using 29 years of longitudinal data. Results point to positive relationships between household income, community vitality, and farm family QOL. Individual stress and economic dependence on farming were negatively associated with QOL. The finding that community vitality is a critical determinant of farm family quality of life supports long-standing appeals to increase investment in community development efforts.
    Journal of Rural Social Sciences. 01/2012; 27(1):84-113.