New ergonomic design criteria for handles of laparoscopic dissection forceps.

Faculty of Design, Engineering and Production, Subfaculty Industrial Design Engineering, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands.
Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques (Impact Factor: 1.19). 03/2001; 11(1):17-26. DOI: 10.1089/10926420150502896
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT The shape of laparoscopic instrument handles can cause physical discomfort. This problem may be ascribed to a lack of standards for instrument design. In this study, new ergonomic requirements for the design of laparoscopic dissection forceps were created. Three representative handles (a Karl Storz [click-line] scissors handle, an Access Plus scissors handle, and an Aesculap cylindrical handle) currently available on the market were evaluated according to the new list of ergonomic criteria.
The handles were subjectively (questionnaire) and objectively (video analyses) tested in order to find out whether the new requirements are valid for the evaluation and design of instrument handles.
The outcome of the subjective and objective tests matched the predictions by the new criteria list. New criteria were introduced (neutral wrist excursions), and existing general criteria were specified (e.g., a minimal contact area of 10 mm). Significant differences were found among the three handles. The Storz handle met 8 of the 10 requirements, the Access handle met 5, and the Aesculap handle met only 4.
The new list of ergonomic requirements is a valid tool to determine the ergonomic value of a handle for laparoscopic dissecting tasks. It gains its strength from its specialized character. Significant differences were found among the three tested handles. Cylindrical handles were inferior to scissors handles.

1 Bookmark
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Laparoscopic pyloromyotomy (LP) for Infantile Hypertrophic Pyloric Stenosis (IHPS) is associated with an increased risk of mucosal tears or incomplete myotomy when compared with open myotomy. Keeping these risks in mind, a new ergonomically designed spreader for LP was developed and investigated in IHPS.METHODS: The new Pyloric Spreader was designed as a 3.5 mm instrument specifically for minimal access application taking into consideration the specific needs of LP.RESULTS: LP was performed using this spreader in 25 infants with IHPS during a 5-year period from 2006-2012. After incising the pylorus using an arthrotomy knife blade, the spreader could be inserted with ease in the pyloric muscle slit and permitted spreading of the pyloric muscle without any circular tears. The axial handle attached to the spreader enable a wide and controlled muscular spreading without mucosal injuries or incomplete spreads. Two infants underwent surgical revision due to recurrent vomiting; however no signs of incomplete myotomy were evident and the vomiting which subsequently subsided was attributed to the preoperative administration of Rotavirus vaccines in these infants.CONCLUSION: The newly designed Pyloric Spreader offers a new ergonomically designed instrument with a flat tip for easy placement in the pyloric muscle slit, broad instrument surface to avoid circular muscle tears, rounded tip edges to prevent mucosal injuries, wide spreading capability for optimal muscle spread and an axial handle for better hand ergonomic for LP in IHPS.
    Technology and health care: official journal of the European Society for Engineering and Medicine 11/2013; · 0.64 Impact Factor
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Abstract Objectives: This study aims to analyze the surgeons' hand spatial configuration during the use of two different instrument handles for laparoscopy, by obtaining information from the data glove CyberGlove®, and establishing existing risk levels for wrist disorders. Material and methods: Fifty surgeons participated in this study and were distributed into three groups (novices, intermediate and experts). Each subject carried out suturing and dissection tasks on a physical simulator, using axial-handled or ring-handled instruments, respectively. Hand and wrist positions were registered by the CyberGlove® and a modified RULA method was applied to establish appropriate risk levels for wrist disorders. Results: We found statistically significant differences in seven of the eleven glove sensors when comparing both tasks. RULA method showed that all subjects, with the exception of the experts using an axial-handled instrument, assume a prejudicial wrist posture during the practice of suturing and dissection tasks on the simulator. Conclusions: Data glove CyberGlove® allows for the distinction between two laparoscopic exercises performed with different instruments. Also, laparoscopic intracorporeal suturing when performed with an axial-handled needle holder entails a more ergonomic posture for the wrist joint. Previous minimally invasive surgical experience is a positive influencing factor on the surgeons' wrist postures during laparoscopy.
    Minimally Invasive Therapy & Allied Technologies 06/2014; 23(6):1-7. · 1.18 Impact Factor
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This review paper discusses the ergonomic challenges associated with laparoscopy in the operating room (OR) and summarizes the practical ergonomic solutions. The literature search was conducted in the fields of laparoscopy and applied ergonomics. Findings indicated that laparoscopic OR staff (surgeons, perioperative nurses and technicians) commonly experienced physical and mental ergonomic risks while working in prolonged static and awkward body positions. This study highlighted the need for more ergonomic interventions in OR environment in order to improve the efficiency of laparoscopy. Ergonomic solutions included utilizing adjustable equipment, placing computer peripherals in optimal locations, providing ergonomic instruments, and improving communication. Understanding the job- or task-related ergonomic risks and hazards could help identify intervention requirements to meet the challenges associated with increased dependency on advanced high technology in the OR.
    Journal of Healthcare Engineering. 12/2012; 3(4):587-604.