Something From “Nothing”-Eight Weak Estrogenic Chemicals Combined at Concentrations Below NOECs Produce Significant Mixture Effects

Centre for Toxicology, Department of Pharmacology, The School of Pharmacy, University of London.
Environmental Science and Technology (Impact Factor: 5.33). 05/2002; 36(8):1751-6. DOI: 10.1021/es0101227
Source: PubMed


We tested whether multicomponent mixtures of xenoestrogens would produce significant effects when each component was combined at concentrations below its individual NOEC or EC01 level. The estrogenic effects of eight chemicals of environmental relevance, including hydroxylated PCBs, benzophenones, parabenes, bisphenol A, and genistein, were recorded using a recombinant yeast estrogen screen (YES). To ensure that no chemical contributed disproportionately to the overall combination effect, a mixture was prepared at a mixture ratio proportional to the potency of each individual component. The performance of four approaches for the calculation of additive combination effects (concentration addition, toxicity equivalency factors, effect summation, and independent action) was compared. Experimental testing of the predictions revealed that concentration addition and its application, the toxicity equivalency factor approach, were valid methods for the calculation of additive mixture effects. There was excellent agreement between prediction and observation. In contrast, independent action and effect summation led to clear underestimations of the experimentally observed responses. Crucially, there were substantial mixture effects even though each chemical was present at levels well below its NOEC and EC01. We conclude that estrogenic agents are able to act together to produce significant effects when combined at concentrations below their NOECs. Our results highlight the limitations of the traditional focus on the effects of single agents. Hazard assessments that ignore the possibility of joint action of estrogenic chemicals will almost certainly lead to significant underestimations of risk.

Download full-text


Available from: Elisabete Silva,

Click to see the full-text of:

Article: Something From “Nothing”-Eight Weak Estrogenic Chemicals Combined at Concentrations Below NOECs Produce Significant Mixture Effects

0 B

See full-text
    • "However, biological responses may also occur as a result of low concentrations of several substances causing an additive or synergistic joint effect (e.g. McDowell et al., 1999; Silva et al., 2002; Pojana et al., 2007) or in the absence of identified causative compound (s) (e.g. Lyons et al., 2006). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Many maritime countries in Europe have implemented marine environmental monitoring programmes which include the measurement of chemical contaminants and related biological effects. How best to integrate data obtained in these two types of monitoring into meaningful assessments has been the subject of recent efforts by the International Council for Exploration of the Sea (ICES) Expert Groups. Work within these groups has concentrated on defining a core set of chemical and biological endpoints that can be used across maritime areas, defining confounding factors, supporting parameters and protocols for measurement. The framework comprised markers for concentrations of, exposure to and effects from, contaminants. Most importantly, assessment criteria for biological effect measurements have been set and the framework suggests how these measurements can be used in an integrated manner alongside contaminant measurements in biota, sediments and potentially water. Output from this process resulted in OSPAR Commission ( guidelines that were adopted in 2012 on a trial basis for a period of 3 years. The developed assessment framework can furthermore provide a suitable approach for the assessment of Good Environmental Status (GES) for Descriptor 8 of the European Union (EU) Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD).
    Marine environmental research 10/2015; DOI:10.1016/j.marenvres.2015.09.010 · 2.76 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Conventional WWTPs eliminate a great amount of compounds but often show a limited reduction of micropollutant concentrations (Daughton and Ternes 1999; Kümmerer 2004). Low residual micropollutant concentrations might still cause negative effects in aquatic organisms (Wick et al. 2009), such as endocrine-disrupting compounds, that are particularly of concern (Orton et al. 2014; Brian et al. 2007; Fent et al. 2006a; Silva et al. 2002). Another important issue is the toxicity of mixtures of micropollutants which can have additive or synergistic effects (Schwarzenbach et al. 2006). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: A mixture of urban and hospital effluents (50 % v/v) was evaluated for ecotoxicity with an advanced bioassay battery. Mixed effluents were tested before any treatment, after biological treatment alone, and after biological treatment followed by a tertiary ozonation (15 mg O3/L). Laying a high value on the continuance of organisms' fitness, essential to preserve a healthy receiving ecosystem, the main objective of this study was to combine normalized bioassays with newly developed in vivo and in vitro tests in order to assess alteration of embryo development, growth and reproduction, as well as genotoxic effects in aquatic organisms exposed to complex wastewater effluents. Comparison of the bioassays sensitivity was considered. Contrary to the lack of toxicity observed with normalized ecotoxicity tests, endpoints measured on zebrafish embryos such as developmental abnormalities and genotoxicity demonstrated a residual toxicity in wastewater both after a biological treatment followed or not by a tertiary O3 treatment. However, the ozonation step allowed to alleviate the residual endocrine disrupting potential measure in the biologically treated effluent. This study shows that normalized bioassays are not sensitive enough for the ecotoxicological evaluation of wastewaters and that there is a great need for the development of suitable sensitive bioassays in order to characterize properly the possible residual toxicity of treated effluents.
    Environmental Science and Pollution Research 09/2015; DOI:10.1007/s11356-015-5419-1 · 2.83 Impact Factor
  • Source
    • "Importantly, the toxicity of single chemicals can be modified when present in a mixture through toxicokinetic interactions with cosolutes , solubility addition (Smith et al., 2013b) or a joint action at the target site, which can enhance or inhibit the effect of endogenous hormones (Carpenter et al., 2002; Silva et al., 2002). It has also been shown that minor changes in mixture composition can cause larger shifts of endocrine responses (Kortenkamp, 2007). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Persistent organic pollutants (POPs) accumulated in human tissues may pose a risk for human health by interfering with the endocrine system. This study establishes a new link between actual human internal POP levels and the endocrine active dose in vitro, applying partitioning-controlled dosing from silicone to the H295R steroidogenesis assay: (1) Measured concentrations of POPs in silicone breast implants were taken from a recent study and silicone disks were loaded according to these measurements. (2) Silicone disks were transferred into H295R cell culture plates in order to control exposure of the adrenal cells by equilibrium partitioning. (3) Hormone production of the adrenal cells was measured as toxicity endpoint. 4-Nonylphenol was used for method development, and the new dosing method was compared to conventional solvent-dosing. The two dosing modes yielded similar dose-dependent hormonal responses of H295R cells. However, with the partitioning-controlled freely dissolved concentrations (Cfree) as dose metrics, dose-response curves were left-shifted by two orders of magnitude relative to spiked concentrations. Partitioning-controlled dosing of POPs resulted in up to 2-fold increases in progestagen and corticosteroid levels at Cfree of individual POPs in or below the femtomolar range. Silicone acted not only as source of the POPs but also as a sorption sink for lipophilic hormones, stimulating the cellular hormone production. Methodologically, the study showed that silicone can be used as reference partitioning phase to transfer in vivo exposure in humans (silicone implants) to in vitro assays (partition-controlled dosing). The main finding was that POPs at the levels at which they are found in humans can interfere with steroidogenesis in a human adrenocortical cell line. Copyright © 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
    Environment International 08/2015; 84:107-114. DOI:10.1016/j.envint.2015.07.008 · 5.56 Impact Factor
Show more