ArticlePDF Available

Value of ultrasound-guided core biopsy in the diagnosis of malignant lymphoma

Authors:

Abstract

Ultrasound-guided core needle biopsy for the diagnosis and management of malignant lymphomas is controversial and has not been accepted as an alternative to surgical biopsy. We investigate the clinical usefulness of this procedure in a large series of patients. Over a 5-year period (2000-2004), ultrasound-guided core needle biopsies were performed in 102 malignant lymphomas. Five diagnostic categories were considered: large B-cell lymphomas (LBCL), small B-cell lymphomas (SBCL), Hodgkin's disease (HD), T cell lymphomas, and miscellaneous. Surgical excisional biopsy of the node was performed in 47 cases (46.1%) for diagnostic confirmation. The overall diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound-guided core needle biopsy was 88.2% (90/102). SBCL (39), LBCL (36), HD (15), T cell lymphomas (5), and miscellaneous (7) [including T cell-rich B cell (2), natural killer cell (1), Burkitt's lymphoma (1), and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma of the B cell type, NOS (3)] were correctly diagnosed. Three HDs, 1 natural killer cell lymphoma, 1 follicular lymphoma, and 1 LBCL were not correctly diagnosed. The core needle biopsy did not yield tumor tissue in 6 cases. Ultrasound-guided core needle biopsy is effective in the diagnosis of malignant lymphomas and can be used as the first diagnostic approach in selected clinical situations.
Value of Ultrasound-Guided Core Biopsy in
the Diagnosis of Malignant Lymphoma
Aitor Ferna
´ndez de Larrinoa, MD,
1
Jose del Cura, MD,
2
Rosa Zabala, MD,
2
Elena Fuertes, MD,
1
Francisco Bilbao, MD,
1
Jose I. Lopez, MD
1
1
Department of Anatomic Pathology, Hospital de Basurto, Avda. de Montevideo 18, Bilbao, 48013 Spain
2
Department of Radiology, Hospital de Basurto, Avda. de Montevideo 18, Bilbao, 48013 Spain
Received 23 June 2006; accepted 2 April 2007
ABSTRACT: Purpose. Ultrasound-guided core needle
biopsy for the diagnosis and management of malig-
nant lymphomas is controversial and has not been
accepted as an alternative to surgical biopsy. We
investigate the clinical usefulness of this procedure in
a large series of patients.
Methods. Over a 5-year period (2000–2004), ultra-
sound-guided core needle biopsies were performed
in 102 malignant lymphomas. Five diagnostic catego-
ries were considered: large B-cell lymphomas (LBCL),
small B-cell lymphomas (SBCL), Hodgkin’s disease
(HD), T cell lymphomas, and miscellaneous. Surgical
excisional biopsy of the node was performed in 47
cases (46.1%) for diagnostic confirmation.
Results. The overall diagnostic accuracy of ultra-
sound-guided core needle biopsy was 88.2% (90/102).
SBCL (39), LBCL (36), HD (15), T cell lymphomas (5),
and miscellaneous (7) [including T cell–rich B cell (2),
natural killer cell (1), Burkitt’s lymphoma (1), and non-
Hodgkin’s lymphoma of the B cell type, NOS (3)] were
correctly diagnosed. Three HDs, 1 natural killer cell
lymphoma, 1 follicular lymphoma, and 1 LBCL were
not correctly diagnosed. The core needle biopsy did
not yield tumor tissue in 6 cases.
Conclusions. Ultrasound-guided core needle biopsy
is effective in the diagnosis of malignant lymphomas
and can be used as the first diagnostic approach in
selected clinical situations. V
V
C2007 Wiley Periodicals,
Inc. J Clin Ultrasound 35:295–301, 2007; Published
online in Wiley InterScience (www.interscience.
wiley.com). DOI: 10.1002/jcu.20383
Keywords: ultrasound; core needle biopsy; lymph-
adenopathy; malignant lymphoma
Image-guided core needle biopsy has become an
important tool in the diagnosis of superficial
and deep masses and can frequently avoid the
need for open biopsy.
1–3
However, it has not
gained general acceptance in the diagnosis of ma-
lignant lymphoma in lymph nodes because the di-
agnosis and subtyping of these neoplasms may be
limited by the small size of the specimen.
4
The first trials to diagnose malignant lym-
phoma using core needle biopsy (CB) were re-
ported 2 decades ago.
5–7
At the same time, fine
needle aspiration cytology procedures were also
implemented with similar objectives
8–11
as the
cytologic diagnosis benefitted from flow cytometry
techniques.
12–14
Although the diagnostic accuracy
of these techniques is high, traditional lymph
node excisional biopsy is still considered by most
pathologists as the method of choice in diagnosing
malignant lymphomas. Several authors have
reported excellent results with image-guided CB
of malignant lymphoma.
5–7,15–26
We present the results of ultrasound-guided
CB in a prospective series of 102 malignant
lymphomas.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
At our institution, imaging-guided CBs are rou-
tinely performed as a diagnostic approach to deep
and superficial tumor masses. During a 5-year
period (2000–2004), a total of 294 lymph nodes
were biopsied under ultrasound guidance, 79 of
them being malignant lymphomas, 113 nonlym-
phoid malignancies, and 102 reactive/inflamma-
tory diseases. In the same period, the spleen was
biopsied in 13 cases, 7 of which were malignant
lymphomas. The series also includes 16 malignant
lymphomas affecting various extranodal sites,
including the liver (4 cases), kidney (2 cases), and
Correspondence to: J. Lopez
'2007 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
VOL. 35, NO. 6, JULY/AUGUST 2007—DOI 10.1002/jcu
295
bowel (1 case). Most cases of malignant lympho-
mas were referred from the hematology clinic.
The study was prospective, and the work-up
included a detailed clinical history and complete
imaging studies (sonography, CT, and MRI when
needed) for all patients.
Procedures were performed using a freehand
technique in all cases. A 4–7-MHz linear trans-
ducer connected o an ATL 3000 or ATL 5000
scanner (Philips Ultrasound 3000, Bothell, WA)
was used to guide the puncture in lesions located
in the head and neck, axilla, thorax, breast,
groin, and extremities (Figure 1A). When the
lesion was located in the abdomen or pelvis, a 2–5-
MHz convex array probe was used. After local
anesthesia with 1% lidocaine, the biopsies were
taken using an 18-gauge BioPince needle (Inter-V,
Gainesville, FL). The biopsy device offers the
possibility to select one of 3 different excursions
of the needle ranging from 1.3 to 3.3 cm. The lon-
gest possible throw that matched with the target
size was selected in every case (Figure 1B). When
the target was an adenopathy and a lymphoma
was clinically suspected, 4 to 5 specimens were
usually obtained trying to avoid the lymph node’s
hilium. When other organs were biopsied, the nee-
dle was preferably directed at the periphery of the
lesion, avoiding central areas, which are fre-
quently necrotic. The gun was always fired when
the point of the needle was placed outside but
close to the boundaries of the lesion in an attempt
to include the capsule in the specimen. Sonogra-
phy was used to verify the correct placement of
the needle through the target lesion.
The obtained tissue fragments were immedi-
ately immersed in cooled saline serum to delay
cellular autolysis, and then forwarded to the pa-
thology department for processing. The receiving
pathologist performed several imprints, and the
saline solution was centrifuged. Imprints were
stained with hematoxylin-eosin and the centrifu-
gate stained with Papanicolaou stain. Some
unstained slides were stored in alcohol for immu-
nohistochemical studies, when needed. Tissue
FIGURE 1. A 70-year-old female with a follicular lymphoma. (A) Sonogram shows a supraclavicular node. (B) Sonogram obtained during the
ultrasound-guided core biopsy shows the brightly echogenic needle through the node. (C) Cytologic imprint shows a monotonous small-sized
lymphoid cell population. (D) Histologic detail of small lymphoid cells showing scarce cytoplasm and hyperchromatic nuclei arranged in a diffuse
pattern of growth.
FERNA
´NDEZ DE LARRINOA ET AL
296
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ULTRASOUND—DOI 10.1002/jcu
cores were processed using routine techniques.
In selected cases, formalin-fixed, paraffin-embed-
ded material was retrieved for molecular analysis
[IgH, TcR, and t(14;18) MBR and JH regions].
Lymph node surgical excision was performed
in 47 cases (46.1%). In the 55 cases in which sur-
gery was not possible or not needed, the definitive
diagnosis was based on hematologic studies, clin-
ical course, previous history, and CB findings.
RESULTS
There was a male predominance in the series (65
males, 37 females) with a mean 6SD age of 70 6
20 years (range, 17–100 years). Location of
lesions and diagnostic categories are summarized
in Table 1. Malignant lymphomas involved lymph
nodes in 79 cases and presented as visceral
masses in 23 cases, 7 of which were in the spleen.
Head and neck (31 cases) and the axilla and groin
(16 and 14 cases, respectively) were most com-
monly affected, with the extremities being very
rarely involved with lymphoma.
No major complications were observed after
CB. Minor hematomas and local pain were occa-
sionally reported, but they resolved spontane-
ously. Post-CB necrosis was found in a splenic
mass but was not directly related to the proce-
dure. Malignant seeding along the needle tract
was not detected.
The diagnostic work-up involved cytologic, his-
tologic, and immunohistochemical studies in all
cases. Molecular studies were performed in 11
cases. Imprints and cytocentrifugates showed
crushing artifacts in lymphoid cells. However,
they were helpful in cases of suboptimal histopa-
thologic slides. Overall, the diagnostic accuracy of
CB in the diagnosis of malignant lymphoma was
88.2% (90/102). There were no false positive cases
in the series. Discordant diagnoses are listed in
Table 2. Three cases of Hodgkin’s disease, 1 natu-
ral killer (NK) cell lymphoma, 1 follicular lym-
phoma, and 1 large B cell lymphoma were not cor-
rectly diagnosed. Additionally, the diagnosis could
not be made in 6 cases due to the fact that the
involved lymph node areas were not adequately
sampled by the radiologist. Interestingly, all the
discordant cases were located superficially in the
neck, axilla, or groin, and most of them (9 out of
12) occurred in the first 2 years of the study.
Small B Cell Lymphoma (39 Cases)
For this type of lymphoma, correlation with sur-
gical/excisional specimens was available in 13
cases (33.3%). Lymph nodes from the head and
neck, including supraclavicular area, were the
most frequently affected (11 cases). Other loca-
tions included the groin (6 cases), axilla (5 cases),
retroperitoneum (4 cases), abdomen (3 cases),
and pelvis, kidney, and breast (1 case each). Sali-
vary glands (parotid and submaxillary) were spe-
cifically affected by this category of lymphomas (6
cases).
Follicular lymphomas amounted to 28 cases
(71.8%), grade 1 cases being the most common
subgroup. Typical cytology and histology and B
cell lineage immunohistochemical markers were
invariably present. In addition, the double bcl-2/
bcl-6–positive immunostaining specifically de-
fined this subcategory. t(14;18) was positive in
6 cases and negative in 5 cases in the molecular
analysis. A total of 7 cases were diagnosed as
small B cell lymphoma, NOS, one of them show-
ing positive IgH rearrangement. Chronic lympho-
cytic lymphoma/leukemia was diagnosed in 3
cases (CD5 and CD23 positivity), and MALT lym-
phoma was diagnosed in 1 case.
Artifacts were not particularly important in
this category, and imprints and cytocentrifugates
displayed with precision the nuclear characteris-
tics in most cases.The histopathologic diagnosis
in this group could not be obtained in 4 cases.
The radiologist obtained nondiagnostic material
in 3 cases. Only one case of follicular lymphoma
was erroneously diagnosed as follicular hyperpla-
sia by the pathologist due to the scarcity of the
TABLE 1
Clinicopathologic Data in 102 Cases of Malignant
Lymphoma Diagnosed on Ultrasound-Guided Core
Needle Biopsy
n(%)
Organ involved
Lymph nodes 79 (77.5)
Spleen 7 (6.8)
Extranodal 16 (15.7)
Location
Head and neck (including supraclavicular fossa) 31 (30.4)
Axilla 16 (15.6)
Groin 14 (13.7)
Viscera 14 (13.7)
Spleen 7
Liver 4
Kidney 2
Bowel 1
Abdomen (extravisceral) 11 (10.8)
Thorax (including breast) 6 (5.9)
Pelvis 2 (1.9)
Extremities 1 (0.9)
Diagnostic categories
Small B cell lymphoma 39 (38.2)
Large B cell lymphoma 36 (35.3)
Hodgkin’s disease 15 (14.7)
T cell lymphoma 5 (4.9)
Others 7 (6.9)
CORE BIOPSY OF MALIGNANT LYMPHOMAS
VOL. 35, NO. 6, JULY/AUGUST 2007—DOI 10.1002/jcu
297
material obtained, which made a complete immu-
nohistochemical study impossible. The diagnostic
accuracy in this group was 89.7%.
Large B Cell Lymphoma (36 Cases)
For this group of lymphomas, correlation with
surgical/excisional specimens was available in 16
cases (44.4%). Lymph nodes in the abdomen (7
cases) and head and neck (6 cases) were the most
commonly affected. Other locations included the
axilla (5 cases), groin (3 cases), thorax (2 cases),
retroperitoneum (2 cases), and breast and arm (1
case each). Interestingly, more than half of lym-
phomas with viscera in our series (9 out of 14,
64.3%) belonged to this category. Among them,
spleen (6 cases), liver (2 cases), and kidney (1
case) involvement were seen.
CBs showed a diffuse lymphoid infiltrate com-
posed of large cells with round nuclei and one or
more nucleoli, as expected in this subtype of lym-
phomas. When the lymphoma involved a viscera,
its normal histology could be recognized in some
areas, sometimes intermingled with the neoplas-
tic lymphoid infiltrate. B cell lineage markers
were positive in all cases. Artifacts were seen at
the periphery of cores, and cell morphology and
immunostaining in these areas had to be eval-
uated with caution.
The diagnostic accuracy of CB in this group
was 94.6%. In fact, the correct diagnosis could
not be reached in only 2 cases. The radiologist
obtained inadequate material in 1 case, and the
pathologist found extensive necrosis in another.
Hodgkin’s Disease (15 Cases)
Correlation with excisional biopsy specimens was
available in 7 cases (47%). Nodular sclerosis (6
cases), mixed cellularity (4 cases), and nodular
lymphocytic predominance (1 case) subtypes were
found. The specific subtype could not be identified
in 4 cases due to the fact that the excisional biopsy
was not performed in these cases.
The diagnostic accuracy in this group was
73.4% (Table 2). The diagnosis of Hodgkin’s dis-
ease greatly depends on the identification of typi-
cal Reed-Sternberg cells, which is a problem
when evaluating small tissue fragments such as
cores.
T Cell Lymphoma (5 Cases)
Correlation with excisional biopsy material ws
available in 4 cases (80%). Aside from the liver (2
cases), lymph nodes in the axilla, groin, and
thorax (1 case each) were involved. There were 4
cases of peripheral T cell lymphoma and 1 case of
chronic lymphocytic leukemia of the T cell type.
Nuclear irregularities and CD3 positive immuno-
staining were typically present. In our experi-
ence, cytologic material was especially useful in
identifying the peculiar nuclear shape of tumor
cells in this category. There was no discrepancy
between CB and excisional biopsy.
Miscellaneous (7 Cases)
Table 3 summarizes the results in this group.
Correlation with excisional biopsy was possible
in 3 cases (42.8%). CB diagnosis was incorrect in
1 NK cell lymphoma and in 1 T cell–rich B cell
lymphoma.
DISCUSSION
In recent years, percutaneous image-guided CB
has been used increasingly in the diagnosis of
lymph node pathology as an alternative to surgi-
TABLE 2
Diagnostic Discrepancies in CB Diagnosis of Malignant Lymphoma (12 Cases)
Case Age/Sex Location CB Diagnosis Final Diagnosis Discordance
1 48/M Groin Nonspecific changes Follicular NHL, grade 1 Inadequate material
2 17/M Neck Nonspecific changes HD, nodular sclerosis Inadequate material
3 72/F Axilla Nonspecific changes LBCL Inadequate material
4 65/M Axilla Necrotic tissue LBCL Insufficient sampling
5 56/F Groin Benign tissue, NOS T-cell rich B-cell NHL Inadequate material
6 79/F Neck Benign tissue, NOS Follicular NHL, grade 1 Inadequate material
7 81/M Axilla Lymphoid proliferation NK cell lymphoma Insufficient sampling
8 40/M Groin Reactive/lymphoma HD, mixed cellularity Insufficient sampling
9 59/M Groin Benign tissue, NOS Follicular NHL, grade 2 Inadequate material
10 48/M Axilla Lymphoid proliferation HD-LPN Insufficient sampling
11 50/M Neck B cell lymphoma HD, nodular sclerosis Insufficient sampling
12 47/M Groin Lymphoid hyperplasia Follicular NHL, grade 1 Insufficient sampling
Abbreviations: HD, Hodgkin’s disease; HD-LPN, Hodgkin’s disease, lymphocytic predominance, nodular type; LBCL, large B cell lymphoma;
NHL, non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, NK, natural killer.
FERNA
´NDEZ DE LARRINOA ET AL
298
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ULTRASOUND—DOI 10.1002/jcu
cal biopsy, particularly if the nodes are deep-
seated or if the clinical condition of the patient is
severely impaired. Sonography and CT show sim-
ilar success when in the hands of an experienced
operator, but sonography is usually preferred
because of its real-time capability.
The widespread use of this technique has
detractors among pathologists, because the scar-
city of the obtained material may make the diag-
nosis and/or subtyping of malignant lymphomas
more difficult.
4
Table 4 summarizes the accumu-
lated experience in this domain and reflects that
the diagnostic concordance between CB and sur-
gical biopsy samples is high (71%–89%). These
data support a more generalized use of this proce-
dure. In fact, de Kerviler et al
17
concluded in
their study on 194 patients that the diagnostic
approach of lymphoma should now be based on
minimally invasive techniques, and Sklair-Levy
et al,
24
after studying 114 cases of lymphoma
using this method, state that image-guided core-
needle biopsy should be considered as a first-step
method in the diagnosis of patients with superfi-
cial lymphadenopathies. Other authors
23
favor
its use in deep masses that would require gene-
ral anesthesia for surgical removal, and still
others
7,25
advise it in the absence of palpable su-
perficial lymph nodes.
Sonographic detection of superficial lymph
nodes was first reported 2 decades ago;
27
since
then, ultrasound-guided needle biopsy has shown
good results in various sites, including the medi-
astinum,
28,29
head and neck,
30
soft tissues,
3
and
spleen.
31
CT has also been used to guide needle
biopsies of the liver,
32
spleen,
33
and pelvis and
retroperitoneum.
34
Image-guided needle biopsy
has also been successfully applied in pediatric
patients.
35
In our experience, CB worked best in the
LBCL group. Indeed, the identification of a dense
population of large lymphoid cells with B cell
immunophenotype in tissue cores is usually suffi-
cient to confirm the diagnosis. We found some-
what similar results in the SBCL group, although
small neoplastic lymphocytes may be mistaken
for nonneoplastic elements if the tissue sample
contains both populations. The presence of B cell
lineage markers, together with the combined pos-
itivity for bcl-2 and bcl-6 in lymphoid cells, is
diagnostic of follicular lymphoma. However, this
combined immunostaining is not always unequiv-
ocal, particularly with bcl-2 and bcl-6 antibodies,
which explains some incomplete diagnoses in our
series. Small cells with CD5 and CD23 positivity,
in addition to the clinical setting, are diagnostic
of lymphocytic lymphoma/leukemia. As reported
previously,
23–25
HD is the most problematic diag-
nosis in CB in our series. The varied histologic
approaches of this disease, the scarcity of the
material for diagnosis, and the frequent absence
of Reed-Sternberg cells in the submitted material
are responsible for these difficulties. Though lim-
ited, our experience in the CB diagnosis of T cell
lymphomas is satisfactory. Nuclear peculiarities
of T cells and CD3-positive immunostaining are
crucial in its recognition. We have not found any
other reports on the diagnosis of T cell lymphoma
in CB, but Yao et al,
9
in their series of 33 cases,
reported that fine needle aspiration cytology is
TABLE 4
Series of Image-Guided CB in Malignant Lymphoma
Study Year
No. of
Cases
Imaging
Guidance
Overall
Diagnostic
Accuracy
of CB
Kalkner et al
5
1994 129 Ultrasound 87%
Ben-Yehuda et al
6
1996 100 CT 78%
Pappa et al
7
1996 106 CT/Ultrasound 83%
Zinzani et al
15
1998 55 Ultrasound 87%
Zinzani et al
16
1999 83 CT/Ultrasound 81%
de Kerviler et al
17
2000 158 CT/Ultrasound 88%
Sklair-Levy et al
18
2000 49 CT 71.5%
Demharter et al
19
2001 65 CT 89.2%
Screaton et al
20
2002 66 Ultrasound 80%
Agid et al
21
2003 267 CT 82.5%
Goldschmidt et al
22
2003 130 CT 75.4%
Balestreri et al
23
2005 137 CT 87%
Sklair-Levy et al
24
2005 114 CT/Ultrasound 84.2%
Li et al
25
2005 80 CT 76.2%
Ravinsky et al
26
2005 28 CT 82%
Present study 102 Ultrasound 88.2%
TABLE 3
Miscellaneous Group of 7 Miscellaneous Malignant Lymphomas Diagnosed on CB
Case Age/Sex Location CB Diagnosis Excisional Diagnosis
1 23/F Ileon Burkitt’s lymphoma ND
2 55/M Spleen NHL, B cell type ND
3 78/M Mesentery NHL, B cell type ND
4 54/M Neck NHL, high-grade NHL, B cell type (autopsy)
5 56/F Groin Benign tissue, NOS T–cell rich B cell lymphoma
6 48/M Retroperitoneum T cell– rich B cell lymphoma ND
7 81/M Axilla Lymphoid proliferation NK cell lymphoma
Abbreviations: ND, not done; NHL, non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma; NK, natural killer.
CORE BIOPSY OF MALIGNANT LYMPHOMAS
VOL. 35, NO. 6, JULY/AUGUST 2007—DOI 10.1002/jcu
299
an accurate diagnostic method. The low fre-
quency of T cell– rich B cell and NK cell lympho-
mas makes diagnosis very difficult and depend-
ent on the quality of the submitted material.
Finally, Burkitt’s lymphoma diagnosis is favored
by the typical clinical setting and histology.
Molecular analysis in our series was per-
formed only to help the pathologic diagnosis
and was particularly helpful in distinguishing
follicular lymphoma from nonneoplastic lymphoid
proliferations.
Ultrasound-guided needle biopsy is a useful
method in the diagnosis of malignant lymphoma,
but optimal results require experienced radiolog-
ists and pathologists. In fact, 9 out of 12 diagnos-
tic failures occurred in the first 2 years of the
study. Tight collaboration between clinicians,
radiologists, and pathologists is the key to suc-
cess. CB is especially useful in patients who are
in poor clinical condition or in any situation that
prevents an open surgical biopsy. Nonetheless,
we believe that open lymph node biopsy still
remains the standard procedure for the complete
histopathologic diagnosis of some malignant
lymphomas.
REFERENCES
1. Libicher M, Noldge G, Radeleff B, et al. Value of
CT-guided biopsy in malignant lymphoma. Radiol-
oge 2002;42:1009.
2. Mintzer DM, Mason BA. On the need for biopsy
confirmation at suspected first recurrence of can-
cer. Am J Clin Oncol 2003;26:192.
3. Lopez JI, del Cura JL, Zabala R, et al. Usefulness
and limitations of ultrasound-guided core biopsy
in the diagnosis of musculoskeletal tumours.
APMIS 2005;113:353.
4. Welch TJ, Sheedy PF II, Johnson CD, et al. CT-
guided biopsy: prospective analysis of 1000 proce-
dures. Radiology 1989;171:493.
5. Kalkner M, Rehn S, Andersson T, et al. Diagnos-
tics of malignant lymphomas with ultrasound
guided 1.2 mm biopsy-gun. Acta Oncol 1994;33:33.
6. Ben-Yehuda D, Polliack A, Okon E, et al. Image-
guided core-needle biopsy in malignant lymphoma:
experience with 100 patients that suggests the
technique is reliable. J Clin Oncol 1996;14:2431.
7. Pappa VI, Hussain HK, Reznek RH, et al. Role of
image-guided core-needle biopsy in the manage-
ment of patients with lymphoma. J Clin Oncol
1996;14:2427.
8. Das DK. Value and limitations of fine needle aspi-
ration cytology in diagnosis and classification of
lymphomas: a review. Diagn Cytopathol 1999;21:
240.
9. Yao JL, Cangiarella JF, Cohen JM, et al. Fine-nee-
dle aspiration biopsy of peripheral T-cell lympho-
mas. A cytologic and immunophenotypic study of
33 cases. Cancer 2001;93:151.
10. Catalano MF, Nayar R, Gress F, et al. EUS-guided
fine needle aspiration in mediastinal lymphade-
nopathy of unknown etiology. Gastrointest Endosc
2002;55:863.
11. Landgren O, Porwit MacDonald A, Tani E, et al. A
prospective comparison of fine-needle aspiration
cytology and histopathology in the diagnosis and
classification of lymphomas. Hematol J 2004;5:69.
12. Siebert JD, Weeks LM, List LW, et al. Utility of
flow cytometry immunophenotyping for the diag-
nosis and classification of lymphoma in community
hospital clinical needle aspiration/biopsies. Arch
Pathol Lab Med 2000;124:1792.
13. Ribeiro A, Vazquez-Sequeiros E, Wiersema LM,
et al. EUS-guided fine-needle aspiration combined
with flow cytometry and immunocytochemistry in
the diagnosis of lymphoma. Gastrointest Endosc
2001;53:485.
14. Laane E, Tani E, Bjo
¨rklund E, et al. Flow cytomet-
ric immunophenotyping including Bcl-2 detection
on fine needle aspirates in the diagnosis of reactive
lymphadenopathy and non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma.
Cytometry B Clin Cytom 2005;64:34.
15. Zinzani PL, Colecchia A, Festi D, et al. Ultra-
sound-guided core-needle biopsy is effective in the
initial diagnosis of lymphoma patients. Haemato-
logica 1998;83:989.
16. Zinzani PL, Corneli G, Cancellieri A, et al. Core
needle biopsy is effective in the initial diagnosis of
mediastinal lymphoma. Haematologica 1999;84:
600.
17. de Kerviler E, Guermazi A, Zagdanski AM, et al.
Image-guided core-needle biopsy in patients with
suspected or recurrent lymphomas. Cancer 2000;
89:647.
18. Sklair-Levy M, Polliack A, Shaham D, et al. CT-
guided core-needle biopsy in the diagnosis of
mediastinal lymphoma. Eur Radiol 2000;10:714.
19. Demharter J, Muller P, Wagner T, et al. Percutane-
ous core-needle biopsy of enlarged lymph nodes in
the diagnosis and subclassification of malignant
lymphomas. Eur Radiol 2001;11:276.
20. Screaton NJ, Berman LH, Grant JW. Head and
neck lymphadenopathy: evaluation with US-
guided cutting-needle biopsy. Radiology 2002;
224:75.
21. Agid R, Sklair-Levy M, Bloom AI, et al. CT-guided
biopsy with cutting-edge needle for the diagnosis
of malignant lymphoma: experience of 267 biop-
sies. Clin Radiol 2003;58:143.
22. Goldschmidt N, Libson E, Bloom A, et al. Clinical
utility of computed tomography-guided core needle
biopsy in the diagnostic re-evaluation of patients
with lymphoproliferative disorders and suspected
disease progression. Ann Oncol 2003;14:1438.
23. Balestreri L, Morassut S, Bernardi D, et al. Effi-
cacy of CT-guided percutaneous needle biopsy in
the diagnosis of malignant lymphoma at first pre-
sentation. Clin Imaging 2005;29:123.
FERNA
´NDEZ DE LARRINOA ET AL
300
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ULTRASOUND—DOI 10.1002/jcu
24. Sklair-Levy M, Amir G, Specte G, et al. Image-
guided cutting-edge-needle biopsy of peripheral
lymph nodes and superficial masses for the diagno-
sis of lymphoma. J Comput Assist Tomogr 2005;
29:369.
25. Li L, Wu QL, Liu LZ, et al. Value of CT-guided
core-needle biopsy diagnosis and classification of
malignant lymphomas using automated biopsy
gun. World J Gastroenterol 2005;11:4843.
26. Ravinsky E, Morales C. Diagnosis of lymphoma by
image-guided needle biopsies: fine needle aspira-
tion biopsy, core biopsy, or both? Acta Cytol 2005;
49:51.
27. Bruneton JN, Normand F, Balu-Maestro C, et al.
Lymphomatous superficial lymph nodes: US detec-
tion. Radiology 1987;165:233.
28. Annessi V, Paci M, De Franco S, et al. Diagnosis of
anterior mediastinal masses with ultrasonically
guided core needle biopsy. Chir Ital 2003;55:
379.
29. Catalano MF, Nayar R, Gress F, et al. EUS-guided
fine needle aspiration in mediastinal lymphade-
nopathy of unknown etiology. Gastrointest Endosc
2002;55:863.
30. Howlett DC, Menezes L, Bell DJ, et al. Ultra-
sound-guided core biopsy for the diagnosis of
lumps in the neck: results in 82 patients. Brit J
Oral Maxillofac Surg 2006;44:34.
31. Lopez JI, del Cura JL, Ferna
´ndez de Larrinoa A,
et al. Role of ultrasound-guided core biopsy in the
evaluation of spleen pathology. APMIS 2006;114:492.
32. Appelbaum L, Lederman R, Agid R, et al. Hepatic
lymphoma: an imaging approach with emphasis
on image-guided needle biopsy. Isr Med Assoc J
2005;7:19.
33. Lieberman S, Libson E, Maly B, et al. Imaging-
guided percutaneous splenic biopsy using a 20- or
22-gauge cutting-edge core biopsy needle for the
diagnosis of malignant lymphoma. AJR Am J
Roentgenol 2003;181:1025.
34. Gupta RK, Cheung YK, alAnsari AG, et al. Value
of image-guided needle aspiration cytology in the
assessment of pelvic and retroperitoneal masses. A
study of 112 cases. Acta Cytol 2003;47:393.
35. Hussain HK, Kingston JE, Domizio P, et al. Imag-
ing-guided core biopsy for the diagnosis of malig-
nant tumors in pediatric patients. AJR Am J
Roentgenol 2001;176:43.
CORE BIOPSY OF MALIGNANT LYMPHOMAS
VOL. 35, NO. 6, JULY/AUGUST 2007—DOI 10.1002/jcu
301
... Mikrokalcifikacija u metastat skim aksilarnim nodusima je retka, ali govori u pri log karcinomu dojke. Slivanje više nodusa i hi pereho genost (usled kalcifikacije) jesu ultrazvučne ka rakte ristike tuberkularnog limfadenitisa (14,15). ...
... Biopsija širokom iglom (Core needle biopsy) predstavlja još jedan dijagnostički metod kojim se do bija veći tkivni uzorak, u poređenju sa FNAC. Uko li ko imidžing tehnika vodi proceduru, rezultati su pre cizniji -preciznost imidžing navođene biopsije širo kom iglom u dijagnozi limfoma iznosi 76-100% (15,16). ...
Article
The majority of patients presenting with peripheral lymphadenopathy have easily identifiable causes that are benign or self-limited. Among primary care patients presenting with lymphadenopathy, the prevalence of malignancy has been estimated to be as low as 1.1 %. The critical challenge for the primary care physician is to identify which cases are secondary to malignancies or other serious conditions. Key risk factors for malignancy include older age, firm, fixed nodal character, duration of greater than two weeks, and supraclavicular location. Knowledge of these risk factors is critical to determining the management of unexplained lymphadenopathy. In addition, a complete exposure history, review of associated symptoms, and a thorough regional examination help determine whether lymphadenopathy is of benign or malignant origin. Unexplained lymphadenopathy without signs or symptoms of serious disease or malignancy can be observed for one month, after which specific testing or biopsy should be performed. While modern hematopathologic technologies have improved the diagnostic yields of fine-needle aspiration, excisional biopsy remains the initial diagnostic procedure of choice.
... Trong phân nhóm chẩn đoán bệnh lý hạch lympho, tỷ lệ chẩn đoán chính xác của chúng tôi là 65,6% và thấp hơn so với nghiên cứu của Huang, De Larrinoa [7,12]. Có thể giải thích là do số BN có hạch u lympho trong nghiên cứu của chúng tôi còn thấp, chưa phản ánh chính xác được toàn bộ nhóm u lympho. ...
Article
Mục tiêu: Đánh giá hiệu quả của kỹ thuật sinh thiết lõi hạch cổ dưới hướng dẫn siêu âm (Ultrasound - guided core needle biopsy - US - CNB) ở nhóm bệnh nhân có hạch nghi ngờ trên lâm sàng và siêu âm. Đối tượng và phương pháp: Nghiên cứu mô tả cắt ngang trên 201 bệnh nhân (BN) có hạch nghi ngờ trên lâm sàng và trên hình ảnh siêu âm, được US-CNB tại Khoa Siêu âm chẩn đoán Bệnh viện Trung ương Quân đội 108 từ tháng 01 năm 2022 đến tháng 9 năm 2023. Kết quả: Tuổi trung bình của nhóm BN nghiên cứu là 55,4 tuổi, nam giới chiếm tỷ lệ cao là 71,1%; Có 88,1% BN được chẩn đoán từ lần đầu US-CNB và không cần sinh thiết mở để chẩn đoán. Có 11,9% BN không chẩn đoán được và cần làm US-CNB lần 2 hoặc sinh thiết mở để bóc hạch làm giải phẫu bệnh. Độ nhạy, độ đặc hiệu và độ chính xác của sinh thiết lõi hạch cổ dưới siêu âm lần lượt là 93,4%, 100% và 95,5%. Tỷ lệ của các nhóm hạch di căn, u lympho, hạch lành tính là 52,2%, 15,9% và 31,9%. Trong nhóm u lympho, độ chính xác của chẩn đoán qua US-CNB là 65,6%. Tai biến thường gặp của kỹ thuật là chảy máu mức độ nhẹ trong hạch và theo đường kim sinh thiết là 2%. Không gặp trường hợp nào tử vong, chảy máu mức độ nặng, nhiễm trùng và tổn thương dây thần kinh. Kết luận: Sinh thiết lõi hạch cổ dưới hướng dẫn siêu âm là một phương pháp chẩn đoán hạch bất thường vùng cổ an toàn và hiệu quả, có độ chính xác cao và ít xâm lấn.
Article
Although surgical biopsy remains the gold standard for the diagnosis of lymphoma, small‐volume biopsies including fine‐needle aspiration and core needle biopsy are increasingly being used as a first line diagnostic tool. Small‐volume biopsies are safe, rapid and cost effective; however, diagnostic utility varies by lymphoma subtype. It is important for pathologists and clinicians to recognize both the strengths and limitations of such biopsies.
Chapter
This chapter explores the different causes of enlarged cervical lymph nodes (LNs), the most common cervical swelling, in both children and adults. Cervical LNs are enlarged in children mainly due to inflammation and in adults mainly due to neoplasms. In adults, LNs tend to be more firm and less tender than those usually found in the neck of children due to recurrent upper respiratory tract infections (URTIs). Cervical lymphadenopathy (CLA) may represent a local neck disease, be a part of a generalized disease such as lymphoma, or reflect a metastatic disease from below the clavicles as in the case of Virchow’s (left supraclavicular) LNs. Based on duration, CLA is further classified into: acute (2 weeks), subacute (2–6 weeks), and chronic (does not resolve by 6 weeks). Suspicious features of LNs on ultrasonography (US) are considered when LNs are rounded, with an irregular contour, internal necrosis, and a lost echogenic hilum. Detection of extracapsular invasion and accurate assessment of their relation to carotid sheath vessels can be achieved by a computed tomography (CT) scan. Assessment of a patient with CLA is not complete without fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC).KeywordsLymph nodesCervical lymphadenopathyInflammationInfectionNeoplasmLymphomaLeukemiaMetastasisVirchow
Article
To compare the diagnostic accuracy of core needle biopsies (CNBs) and surgical excisional biopsies (SEBs), samples of lymphoid proliferation from a single institution from 2013 to 2017 (N=476) were divided into groups of CNB (N=218) and SEB (N=258). The diagnostic accuracy of these samples was evaluated as a percentage of conclusive diagnosis, according to the World Health Organization Classification of Tumours of Haematopoietic and Lymphoid Tissues. The contribution of clinical data, the assessment of sample adequacy by a pathologist during the procedure, the number and size of fragments, the needle gauge, the ancillary tests, and the type of lymphoid proliferation were also examined. The diagnostic accuracy of SEB was 97.3% and CNB 91.3% (P=0.010). Additional factors considered essential for establishing the final diagnosis in some cases were: clinical information (20.6% CNB, 7.4% SEB; P<0.001); immunohistochemistry (96.3% CNB, 91.5% SEB; P=0.024); flow cytometry (12% CNB, 6.8% SEB; P=0.165); and other complementary tests (8.2% CNB, 17.3% SEB; P=0.058). Factors that did not influence performance were the evaluation of sample adequacy during the procedure, the number and size of fragments, and the needle gauge. Increased percentage of nondiagnostic CNB was observed in T-cell lymphomas (30%), followed by classic Hodgkin lymphoma (10.6%). The main limitation of CNB was the evaluation of morphologically heterogenous diseases. CNB is useful and safe in lymphoma diagnosis provided it is carried out by a team of experienced professionals. Having an interventional radiology team engaged with pathology is an essential component to achieve adequate rates of specific diagnoses in CNB specimens.
Article
AIM To compare technical success, diagnostic accuracy, and histological yield of fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC), side-cutting (Temno) needle biopsy, and end-cutting (Franseen) needle biopsy for ultrasound-guided sampling of groin and axillary lymph nodes. MATERIALS AND METHODS A total of 270 abnormal groin and axillary nodes were sampled using one of the three techniques. Nodes with a maximum length of <2.5 cm underwent FNAC or Franseen biopsy, while nodes >2.5 cm underwent Temno biopsy. Mean size of nodes sampled by FNAC (21.2 mm) and Franseen (19.7 mm) were similar while nodes sampled by Temno were larger (34.4 mm, p<0.0001). RESULTS Technical success rates of FNAC (82/93, 88%), Franseen (105/111, 95%), and Temno (59/66, 89%) biopsies were similar (p>0.05 for all). Lymphoid tissue yield by FNAC (mean total area 1.51 mm²) was less than that by Franseen (7.14 mm², p=0.002) or Temno biopsy (19.44 mm², p<0.0001). Diagnostic accuracy for malignancy was lower for FNAC (22/30, 73%) than Franseen (25/26, 96%, p=0.02) or Temno biopsy (32/32, 100%, p=0.002). For malignant nodes, determining the likely organ of origin was also lower for FNAC (7/30, 23%) than Franseen (19/26, 73%, p=0.0002) or Temno biopsy (29/32, 91%, p<0.0001), with a similar pattern observed in the identification of lymphoma. CONCLUSION For similarly sized nodes, Franseen biopsy provided more lymphoid material, a higher diagnostic accuracy for malignancy including lymphoma, and better identification of the likely organ of origin than FNAC. Routine use of Franseen biopsy is advocated rather than FNAC for percutaneous sampling of lymph nodes not suitable for side-cutting needle biopsy.
Article
Objective: The objective is to study the efficacy of fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) and core-needle biopsy (CNB) in the diagnosis of lymphoma in a single institution. Study design: We retrospectively reviewed 635 FNAB/CNB cases performed in our institution to rule out lymphoma during a 4-year period and collected the relevant clinical and pathological information for statistical analysis. Results and conclusions: This cohort comprised 275 males and 360 females, with a median age of 57 years. Among the 593 cases with adequate diagnostic materials for lymphoma work-up, 226 were positive for lymphoma, 286 were negative for lymphoma, and 81 were nondiagnostic. Each case had an FNAB, and 191 cases also underwent a CNB. The subclassification rate according to the WHO (2008) was 67% overall, 81% for the FNAB with CNB group, and 40% for the FNAB group. In the FNAB with CNB group, the subclassification rates for cases with and without a history of lymphoma were not significantly different. A definitive diagnosis of lymphoma relied on ancillary studies, but was not affected by location, or the needle gauge of CNB. Follow-up data revealed a high diagnostic accuracy of FNAB with CNB. In conclusion, the use of FNAB and CNB with ancillary studies is effective in providing a definitive diagnosis of lymphoma in our experience at the Northwell Health System.
Article
Background The diagnostic yield of core needle biopsies (CNB) in cervical lymphadenopathy for lymphoma diagnosis is controversial. The aim of this study was to calculate the accuracy of cervical CNB in diagnosing lymphoma. Methods We conducted a meta‐analysis of all studies on patients presenting with cervical lymphadenopathy and referred to CNB. Patients with a diagnosis other than lymphoma were excluded. All cases diagnosed with lymphoma sufficient to guide treatment based on CNB outcome were considered accurate (actionable) results. A separate meta‐analysis was performed for various lymphoma subtypes. Results Three prospective and 19 retrospective studies, comprising 1120 patients, met the inclusion criteria. The rate of actionable lymphoma diagnoses following CNB ranged from 30% to 96.3%, with a random‐effects model of 82.45% (95% confidence interval [CI] =0.76‐0.88) and a fixed‐effects model of 78.3% (95% CI =0.75‐0.80). Conclusion CNB for cervical lymphadenopathy in lymphoma cases is relatively accurate in guiding treatment.
Article
Purpose This study aimed to compare the efficacy and safety of image-guided core needle biopsy (CNB) with those of surgical excision biopsy (SEB) for the diagnosis of lymphoma, and to clarify the indication of CNB in clinical practice. Method This retrospective study included 263 image-guided CNB cases and 108 SEB cases that were performed at our institution between January 2014 and December 2018. The rate of patients with performance status of grade 1–4 was higher in the CNB group than in the SEB group (43.7% vs. 24.1%, P < 0.01). Waiting time to biopsy and diagnosis was shorter for CNB group than for SEB group (4 days vs. 7 days, 13 days vs. 15 days, P < 0.01). The rate of biopsy at the deep sites was higher in the CNB group than in the SEB group (53.2% vs. 8.3%, P < 0.01). Successful biopsy and complication rates were compared between the 2 groups. Results There were no significant differences between the CNB and SEB groups in successful biopsy rates (89.0% vs. 93.5%, P = 0.25). The grade 3 complication rate was significantly lower for CNB group than for SEB group (0% vs. 4.6%, P < 0.01), although there was no significant difference in overall complication rates (4.9% vs. 6.5%, respectively, P = 0.61). Conclusions CNB showed high diagnostic yield comparable to SEB for suspected lymphoma. CNB was especially recommended to the cases with low-PS, lesions in the deep sites, and requiring early pathological diagnosis.
Article
Background Despite current guidelines, a significant increase in the use of core needle biopsy (CNB) has been noted. Our aims were to determine the profile of patients referred for image-guided biopsies, to assess the diagnostic yield of these biopsies, and whether CNB is an effective alternative to surgical excision (SEB). Methods All lymph node biopsies evaluated in the Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine from 2014 to 2017 were included. Patients’ demographics, type of biopsy and the final diagnosis were recorded and divided into diagnostic and non-diagnostic. The reasons for the latter were evaluated and follow up was obtained, where available. Results 373 cases, 210 cores and 163 excisional biopsies were collected. The diagnostic yield was 79% for CNB compared to 97% for SEB. The choice of CNB versus SEB was not dependent on patient’s age, gender or the clinical suspicion of malignancy. Failure to reach a diagnosis was due to insufficient or suboptimal tissue in the majority of non-diagnostic CNB. Lymphoma was equally diagnosed among CNB and SEB. CNB was at an advantage in diagnosing large B cell lymphomas. Conclusion When performed adequately, CNB is a good substitute to SEB. Strict and specific guidelines need to be updated and adopted to direct on how and when it can be used, including the recommendation of concomitant complementary diagnostic laboratory testing such as flow cytometry. The latter should be readily available in order not to compromise the quality and the accuracy of the rendered diagnoses.
Article
Full-text available
Context.—Flow cytometry immunophenotyping (FC) of needle aspiration/biopsy (NAB) samples has been reported to be useful for the diagnosis and classification of lymphoma in university and cancer center–based settings. Nevertheless, there is no agreement on the utility of these methods. Objective.—To further define the utility of adjunctive FC of clinical NAB for the diagnosis and classification of lymphoma, and to determine if this approach is practicable in a routine clinical practice setting. Setting.—A community-based hospital. Methods.—Clinical NABs were submitted for adjunctive FC between June 1996 and September 1999 if initial smears were suspicious for lymphoma. Smears and cell block or needle core tissues were routinely processed and paraffin-section immunostains were performed if indicated. The final diagnosis was determined by correlating clinical and pathologic data, and the revised European-American classification criteria were used to subtype lymphomas. Results.—Needle aspiration/biopsies from 60 different patients were submitted for FC. Final diagnoses were lymphoma (n = 38), other neoplasm (n = 15), benign (n = 6), or insufficient (n = 1). For 38 lymphomas (20 primary, 18 recurrent), patients ranged in age from 32 to 86 years (mean, 62 years); samples were obtained from the retroperitoneum (n = 11), lymph node (n = 9), abdomen (n = 8), mediastinum (n = 6), or other site (n = 4); and lymphoma subtypes were indolent B-cell (n = 20; 2 small lymphocytic, 14 follicle center, 4 not subtyped), aggressive B-cell (n = 14; 3 mantle cell, 10 large cell, 1 not subtyped), B-cell not further specified (n = 2), or Hodgkin disease (n = 2). For the diagnosis of these lymphomas, FC was necessary in 20 cases, useful in 14 cases, not useful in 2 cases, and misleading in 2 cases. Thirty-two of 36 lymphoma patients with follow-up data received antitumor therapy based on the results of NAB plus FC. Conclusions.—Adjunctive FC of NABs is potentially practicable in a community hospital, is necessary or useful for the diagnosis and subtyping of most B-cell lymphomas, and can help direct lymphoma therapy. Repeated NAB or surgical biopsy is necessary for diagnosis or treatment in some cases.
Article
Full-text available
AIM: To evaluate the value of CT-guided core-needle biopsy in diagnosis and classification of malignant lymphomas. METHODS: From January 1999 to October 2004, CT-guided core-needle biopsies were performed in 80 patients with suspected malignant lymphoma. Biopsies were performed with an 18-20 G biopsy-cut (CR Bard, Inc., Covington, GA, USA) needle driven by a spring-loaded Bard biopsy gun. RESULTS: A definite diagnosis and accurate histological subtype were obtained in 61 patients with a success rate of 76.25% (61/80). Surgical sampling was performed in 19 patients (23.75%) with non-diagnostic core-needle biopsies. The success rate of CT-guided core-needle biopsy varied with the histopathologic subtypes in our group. The relatively high success rates of core-needle biopsy were noted in diffuse large B-cell non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma (NHL, 88.89%) and peripheral T-cell NHL (90%). However, the success rates were relatively low in anaplastic large cell (T/null cell) lymphoma (ALCL, 44.44%) and Hodgkin’s disease (HD, 28.57%) in our group. CONCLUSION: CT-guided core-needle biopsy is a reliable means of diagnosing and classifying malignant lymphomas, and can be widely applied in the management of patients with suspected malignant lymphoma. Keywords: Malignant lymphoma, Biopsy, Computed tomography Citation: Li L, Wu QL, Liu LZ, Mo YX, Xie CM, Zheng L, Chen L, Wu PH. Value of CT-guided core-needle biopsy in diagnosis and classification of malignant lymphomas using automated biopsy gun. World J Gastroenterol 2005; 11(31): 4843-4847
Article
The fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytologic diagnosis of non‐Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) depends upon finding a relatively monotonous population of lymphoid cells in smears. Lymphomas have successfully been classified by FNA cytology following the prevalent histologic classifications. The success rate of FNA cytology ranges from 80%–90% in diagnosis of NHL and from 67.5%–86% in its subtyping. The cytodiagnosis of Hodgkin's disease (HD) depends upon demonstration of Reed‐Sternberg cells or Hodgkin's cells amongst appropriate reactive cell components. The diagnostic accuracy of FNA cytology for HD has also been invariably high (>85%). Yet, the role of cytology in primary diagnosis, subclassification and management of patients with lymphoma remains controversial. The differential diagnostic problems for NHL include a group of small round cell tumors, nonlymphoid acute leukemias and HD. Reservations have been expressed regarding the efficacy of cytology in separating florid reactive hyperplasia from low‐grade malignant lymphoma. The reported cytodiagnostic accuracy for follicullar lymphomas and nodular sclerosis type of HD is less compared to other subtypes of NHL and HD respectively since nodular pattern and sclerosis are strict histologic criteria which can not be appreciated in cytologic preparations. Entities like atypical lymphoproliferative disorders, peripheral T‐cell lymphomas and Ki‐1 positive anaplastic large cell lymphomas pose diagnostic challenges to cytologists. Despite these limitations, FNA cytology remains the first line of investigations (screening test) used in cases of lymphadenopathy. Besides initial diagnosis of lymphoma, it helps in detection of residual disease, recurrences and progression of low‐grade to high‐grade lymphoma, and helps in staging the disease. Availability of prior FNA cytology report facilitates the histologic diagnosis and classification of NHL. Various special ancillary techniques are now being performed on lymph node aspirates to diagnose lymphoma versus other malignancies, and to decide the functional character of lymphomas and their clonal nature. Diagn. Cytopathol. 1999;21:240–249. © 1999 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.
Article
At the time of suspected first recurrence of cancer, it is unclear whether biopsy confirmation is routinely performed, although this is a very common clinical situation. First, 20 oncologists were surveyed to ascertain the pattern of practice in our community. A questionnaire with hypothetical typical cases suspected of having recurrent cancer was distributed. Second, eligibility criteria were reviewed from investigational protocols from the National Cancer Institute (NCI) and the Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group to see whether confirmation of recurrence was specifically required in these research studies. Third, 64 cases from our own practice were reviewed retrospectively to deter-mine our patterns and results in performing biopsies to document suspected recurrence. Finally, criteria were developed that might suggest the need for biopsy confirmation of recurrence and then retrospectively tested against our cases. There was no clear consensus among oncologists regarding the need for tissue confirmation in patients with solid tumor with suspected recurrences, although rebiopsy was routinely requested for recurrent lymphoma. Published Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group and NCI protocols reviewed did not require biopsy proof specifically of recurrence. Retrospective review of our own cases suggested that, in the absence of one of the proposed indicators, the risk of making an erroneous diagnosis without biopsy confirmation is low. It is suggested that biopsy is not routinely necessary for confirmation of recurrence in all cases of suspected recurrent solid tumors, but criteria are proposed that would help to reduce the possibility of misdiagnosis when biopsy of suspected recurrence is not performed.
Article
Objective To determine whether or not concurrent core biopsy adds to results obtained from image-guided fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) in cases of lymphoma. Study Design Twenty-eight FNABs of lymphomas with adjuvant flow cytometry (FC) and concurrent core biopsy were evaluated retrospectively. In each case, completeness of diagnosis by FNAB, including phenotyping and grading, where appropriate, was reviewed. The contribution of core biopsy to the diagnosis in cases where FNAB did not render a complete diagnosis was assessed. Prognostic information not available from the FNAB but obtained from the core biopsy was also evaluated. Results FNAB with adjuvant FC gave a complete diagnosis, including phenotype and grade, where applicable, in 23 of 28 cases (82%). Core biopsy added to the diagnosis in 3 cases. In 1 case, large B-cell lymphoma was diagnosed on core biopsy when FNAB was unsatisfactory. In the other 2 cases, grade of follicle center cell lymphoma was higher on core biopsy than on FNAB. The addition of the information obtained by core biopsy to that obtained by FNAB raised the diagnostic accuracy to 93%. Core biopsy was used to assess nodularity, which could not be determined on FNAB. Core biopsy was also used to asses prognostic markers by immunobistochemistry (Ki-67 and p53); they were not available with FC. This was done in 11 cases when requested by the oncologist. Conclusion FNAB with adjuvant FC is a useful technique for diagnosing and subtyping lyinphomas. However, diagnosis and subclassification are often insufficleat. Core biopsy material provides opportunity for obtaining additional diagnostic and prognostic information that may not be easily derived from the FNAB. This allows optimal treatment planning in patients for whom excisional biopsy is contraindicated.
Article
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the diagnostic value of the noninvasive method of image-guided needle aspiration cytology (NAC) in the assessment of radiologically detected pelvic and retroperitoneal space-occupying lesions (excluding the pancreas, kidney and adrenal). STUDY DESIGN: NAC was performed under computed tomographic or ultrasound guidance on 112 patients suspected of having a pelvic or retroperitoneal mass. Cytologic examination was performed on site after staining smears with the Papanicolaou method. In addition, air-dried smears, fixed smears, filter preparations from needle washings and cell blocks were studied. The NAC diagnosis was supported by examining cell blocks; further support was obtained with a tissue biopsy in some cases. Additionally, pertinent immunoperoxidase and/or histochemical studies were done. RESULTS: Eighteen cases were diagnosed as inflammatory lesions, 17. cases consisted of normal cellular elements, and 12 cases showed scanty material and were considered unsatisfactory/inadequate for a diagnosis. Five cases were suspicious for malignancy, and in 39 cases metastatic tumors were diagnosed from a previously known primary. Thirteen cases were diagnosed as lymphoma, and in 8 cases a diagnosis of soft tissue sarcoma was made. There were no false positive diagnoses of malignancy. Cell block preparations and immunohistochemistry were helpful with tumor typing, although lymphoma subtyping and soft tissue tumor typing generally required open biopsy. CONCLUSION: NAC; as the first-line investigation, is not only. useful in the diagnosis of space-occupying lesions of the pelvic and retroperitoneal region but can also help in choosing appropriate management. The technique is most useful in diagnosing metastases but is also helpful in excluding malignancy in some cases and in suggesting diagnoses of lymphomas and soft tissue tumors.
Article
Management of diagnosing malignant lymphomas has changed with development of CT-guided techniques and reliable biopsy tools.Pathologists can use representative tissue samples for sub classification in more than 90%.Evaluation of residual lymphoma or relapse can be nearly as effective. Therefore percutaneous biopsy can be considered as primary diagnostic tool in the absence of peripheral lymphadenopathy. CT-guided biopsies can be performed on an outpatient basis under conscious sedation considering contraindications as well as regional complications. Acceptance of percutaneous biopsy by the pathologist and oncologist is based on diagnostic effectiveness that is significantly improved if more than 3†solid tissue samples are taken. This article reviews the value of CT-guided biopsy in comparison to surgical procedures in patients with malignant lymphoma. Essential aspects that lead to a diagnostic percutaneous biopsy are discussed on grounds of the current literature.
Article
The authors prospectively analyzed 1,000 biopsies guided with computed tomography (CT) and performed in 955 patients over a 30-month period. All patients were followed up from 3 months to 2 years. The biopsies were performed in an average of 22 minutes (range, 3-85 minutes) by 26 different radiologists; five radiologists performed 547 of the procedures. Of the 1,000 biopsies, 722 were performed in areas in the liver, retroperitoneum, pancreas, pelvis, and adrenal glands. Of 69 errors in diagnosis, 67 were falsely negative and two were falsely positive; 747 true-positive and 184 true-negative diagnoses were made. CT-directed biopsy for accurate diagnosis was 91.8% sensitive and 98.9% specific, with a positive predictive value of 99.7% and a negative predictive value of 73.3%. Of 11 patients with complications, seven had hematomas, three had pneumothorax, and one had hematuria. No deaths occurred, and only one patient required surgery.
Article
Superficial adenopathy is the most frequent clinical manifestation of lymphoma, both at initial workup and later when disease recurs. Data obtained by means of physical examination and ultrasonography (US) of the cervicosupraclavicular, axillary, and inguinal regions were compared for 120 patients, 60 at the time of initial staging and 60 during follow-up for a previously treated lymphoma. Twenty-nine in the second group had recurrent disease, as confirmed with histologic examination. For all 120 patients, US revealed clinically impalpable lesions in an average of 10.8% of cases for the cervicosupraclavicular region, 17.9% for the axillary region, and 4.1% for the inguinal region. Eight of the 29 relapses were not detected at physical examination, and three were demonstrated solely with US. These findings emphasize the value of US exploration of the superficial node-bearing regions in patients with lymphoma, during both initial staging and follow-up.